A/50/476
English
Page 7
first for the United Nations. However, in your discussion of various
manifestations of anti-Semitism, you make several statements which are
inaccurate and troubling. In paragraph 22 you write that anti-Semitism is
’compounded by the economic power of the Jews’. Such a statement is
problematic, endorsing one of the most pervasive - and ungrounded stereotypes about Jews: that they are especially materialistic, are
greedy, and wield disproportionate economic power. You will no doubt agree
that such charges are neither accurate nor made with discriminatory purpose
against other groups, such as the Swiss Protestants who run many of
Geneva’s most powerful banks. Yet by citing this stereotype as a fact, you
suggest that Jews are somehow to blame for discrimination against them;
that it is somehow their own fault (because they wield economic power) that
they are subjected to anti-Semitism.
"In a later paragraph, 37, you write that anti-Semitism is further
caused by ’certain adherents of Judaism [who] continue to treat Christ as
an impostor’. This statement is troubling, for it implies both that some
Jews have come to accept Christ, and that others actively set out to
discredit him. What you should understand is that for Jews, as for all
other non-Christians, Christ is a figure of solely historical and moral
significance. This does not imply that Jews in any way disparage Christ;
merely that the basis for Judaism is pre-Christian and independent of
Christ’s teachings. Despite their manifest similarities, Judaism and
Christianity are quite separate religions, with different belief systems
and different pivotal figures." 5/
12. As he has already had occasion to stress in his written and oral
replies 6/ to the comments which have been communicated to him, the Special
Rapporteur wishes to stress that the opinions expressed in these paragraphs are
not his own. He has endeavoured, in seeking the causes of anti-Semitism, as he
has done in the case of negrophobia, to take stock of the reasons advanced in
explanation of these phenomena.
13. The Rapporteur would also like to stress that it was as a consequence of
his preliminary report to the Commission on Human Rights in February 1994 that,
with his approval, his mandate was extended to include the question of
anti-Semitism, which he considers to be a form of racial discrimination which
has led to one of the greatest scourges that the world has known in the past and
continues to experience today.
2.
The situation of housekeepers of Indian, Sri Lankan, Bengali
and Philippine origin in Kuwait
14. Referring to aspects of a study which had been transmitted to him by the
organization Middle East Watch/Women’s Rights Project, 7/ the Special
Rapporteur, included, in paragraph 108 of his report, the following
observations:
"In Kuwait, housekeepers of Indian, Sri Lankan, Bengali and Philippine
origin are now targets of rape, physical assault, non-payment of salaries,
debt bondage and abusive work conditions because of their nationality.
/...