A/57/274
51. Methodists reportedly face refusal from the
authorities of the region of Transdniester to register
them. It is reported that Dmitri Hantil, a Methodist
leader, has requested registration for two communities
three times during the past six years and that a Captain
Soin of the National Security Ministry not only warned
him to stop applying for registration for his churches
with the Transdniestran authorities but also asked him
to cease cooperating with international organizations.
Turkey
52. On 21 February 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent
allegations to the Government of Turkey concerning
the following cases. On 13 February 2002, local
authorities in nine provinces of Turkey, under alleged
orders from the Turkish Interior Ministry, reportedly
launched judicial proceedings questioning the legality
of designated places of worship used by some 40 small
Protestant church groups across the country. Formal
notifications have reportedly been delivered to 23
congregations of Turkish Christians in Istanbul,
Ankara, Diyarbakir, Bursa and Mersin, allegedly
declaring that their rented or purchased places of
worship were in violation of municipal building laws
and informing the congregations that, if they continued
to meet in a place not officially zoned for religious use,
legal action would be taken against them. Court cases
pertaining to these charges are reportedly under way
concerning Protestant groups in Izmir, Istanbul, Mersin
and Gaziantep.
“In recent years, some Protestant groups
have begun using certain areas, which are
designated for residences, shops and offices, as
places of worship. At the request of several
governorships, the Directorate General of
Security sent them the rules to be applied. Those
rules are listed in Turkey’s reply. No action was
taken by the administration for the closure of
existing places of worship. However, complaints
have been filed to the Public Prosecutor’s
Offices. The governorships of Antalya, Aydin and
Mugla have been authorized to allow the use of
historical churches for acts of worship and
religious services by everyone, after restoration
by the Ministry of Culture. Furthermore, upon the
application of a group named Independent
Protestant Churches in Izmir, Aya Vukla Church,
which was in the possession of the Ministry of
Justice, has been designated as a place of worship
for this group.”
Turkmenistan
55. On 4 March 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent
allegations to the Government of Turkmenistan
concerning the following cases. On 10 February 2002,
police reportedly raided a private home where six
Protestants were gathering in the city of Ashgabat,
allegedly fined the four adults present and threatened
the home owner with the confiscation of her home and
with deportation.
53. Reportedly, a directive entitled “requests to open
places of worship”, allegedly issued on 17 August 2001
and signed by the Under-Secretary of the Interior
Ministry, Muzaffer Ecemis, referred to the Turkish
Penal Code, which prohibits the use of apartment flats,
shops and detached buildings as places of worship by
Protestants, Baha’is, Jehovah’s Witnesses and
Believers in Christ. It also reportedly declares that
conducting Sunday schools, Bible schools or other
religious education without permission from the
Turkish Education Ministry is punishable with fines
and prison sentences. In contrast, 81 per cent of the
mosques under construction in the country have
apparently obtained no licence, and 55 per cent have
reportedly not even drawn up an architectural plan.
56. In November 2001 in Turkmenabat, Maryam
Ismakaeva and five members of the Seventh-day
Adventist Church were reportedly arrested at
Ms. Ismakaeva’s apartment and their documents seized,
including Ms. Ismakaeva’s document of ownership for
her apartment. Allegedly, a statement of claim was sent
by the city authorities to the court, in which Ms.
Ismakaeva was officially accused of holding religious
meetings of Adventist members in her apartment and it
was stated that she should be evicted and not provided
with any other place to live. Ms. Ismakaeva reportedly
not only lost her apartment but also her registration in
the country and had to leave the country.
54. By letter dated 18 June 2002, Turkey referred to
the constitutional provisions applicable in this instance
and replied, inter alia, that:
57. On 4 March 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent a
communication to the Government of Zimbabwe
regarding 11 Christians, including 4 clergymen who
were reportedly arrested on 16 February 2002 while
10
Zimbabwe