A/57/292
IV. Conceptual and substantive
development of the question of the
human rights of migrants
25. In her first report (E/CN.4/2000/82), the Special
Rapporteur proposed that the following persons should
be considered as migrants:
(a) Persons who are outside the territory of the
State of which they are nationals or citizens, are not
subject to its legal protection and are in the territory of
another State;
(b) Persons who do not enjoy the general legal
recognition of rights which is inherent in the granting
by the host State of the status of refugee, naturalized
person or of similar status;
(c) Persons who do not enjoy either general
legal protection of their fundamental rights by virtue of
diplomatic agreements, visas or other agreements.
26. In paragraph 30 of that report, the Special
Rapporteur stressed that “in the light of the political,
social, economic and environmental situation of many
countries, it is increasingly difficult, if not impossible,
to make a clear distinction between migrants who leave
their countries because of political persecution,
conflicts,
economic
problems,
environmental
degradation or a combination of these reasons and
those who do so in search of conditions of survival or
well-being that do not exist in their places of origin”.
The Special Rapporteur also noted the challenge of
how to define migrant population in a way that takes
account of new situations and how to reflect that
concept in international instruments.
27. Since the establishment of her mandate, the
Special Rapporteur has tried to draw attention to the
situation of thousands of persons in various countries
who do not benefit from protection under the
Convention on the Status of Refugees and who
nevertheless flee from situations of persecution and
open warfare. It has been a matter of deep concern to
the Special Rapporteur to observe the situation of
thousands of persons in various countries of the world
who are fearful of applying for refugee status or who
are denied that status and go underground and become
illegal migrants. The Special Rapporteur has reiterated
the necessity for States Parties to the Convention of
1951 and the Protocol of 1967 to fulfil their obligations
under these instruments. She has also reminded States
12
that international human rights instruments constitute a
legal framework for the protection of migrants and
that, in this connection, the status of illegal migrant
should not be used as justification for the violation of
their rights.
A. Discrimination
28. Many countries have discriminatory laws and
practices against foreigners seeking work in a country
of which they are not nationals. The granting or denial
of visas based on the particular national origin of the
applicant and on the grounds of national security are
some of the common realities facing migrant workers
and which are a cause of concern to the Special
Rapporteur. Also of concern to the Special Rapporteur
are the proliferation of political platforms with antimigrant language in many Western countries, acts of
racial violence and xenophobia committed by extremist
groups, and the use of negative and discriminatory
stereotypes about migrants in the communication
media. The Special Rapporteur is also concerned at the
recent reports published by Human Rights Watch and
Amnesty International on the situation of migrants in
Spain and, in particular, all forms of discriminatory
treatment towards them. 2
29. The situation of the migrant in the face of
discrimination, xenophobia and intolerance has been
described at length by the Special Rapporteur in her
reports (see A/CONF.189/PC.1/19 on the specific
question of discrimination against women). The
Special Rapporteur has noted how discrimination and
marginalization are reasons for emigration from the
country of origin. In addition, the existence of
xenophobic and discriminatory attitudes in the
migration process itself continues to give cause for
concern. The Special Rapporteur considers that at the
heart of the problem are the everyday customs in which
the problem most clearly manifests itself. These
customs have developed because of the existence of
certain stereotypes, which must be rooted out by taking
specific measures to vigorously promote human rights,
democracy and cultural pluralism.
30. The measures agreed upon at the World
Conference against Racism, Racial Discrimination,
Xenophobia and Related Intolerance must therefore be
translated into concrete national service and preventive
programmes that take into account all vulnerable
groups that have been identified. During the