A/HRC/59/49
circumstances in which such persons are found, and any search and rescue unit receiving
information about a distress incident is obliged to take immediate action if in a position to
assist. 51 Coastal States have the duty to establish national search and rescue zones in
cooperation with neighbouring States, to take primary responsibility for responding to search
and rescue incidents that occur within their region and for ensuring effective coordination
and cooperation.52
IV. Contributing factors and root causes of migrant
disappearances
A.
Militarization, securitization and criminalization of migration
29.
One of the reasons for the increase in the risk of being subjected to disappearance,
including enforced disappearance, is connected to the growing externalization of migration
governance and the intensification of border controls, coupled with increasing securitization
and deterrence measures.53 The documented use of military and security forces, including by
private actors, to manage migration at international borders exacerbates the dangers leading
to disappearance, including enforced disappearance. 54 In Mexico, a recent constitutional
reform allows the armed forces, the army and the national guard to take on the dual role of
combating organized crime and human trafficking. Such practices could result in a failure to
distinguish between migrants in transit and individuals associated with criminal groups.55
30.
These forms of border militarization frequently constitute deterrence measures by
either purposefully funnelling migrants into more geographically dangerous terrain where the
risk of disappearance is heightened or by subjecting them to criminalization. The Italian
Government, for example, issued a decree establishing a new criminal offense for “death or
injury as a consequence of illegal immigration offences”, punishable by 20 to 30 years in
prison.56 In the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, through the adoption
of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, the Government made changes to the 1971
Immigration Act, expanding the range of circumstances in which crossings of the English
Channel could be considered criminal.57
31.
Furthermore, strategies to combat trafficking, often resulting in the militarization of
borders, force migrants to geographically dangerous areas where they can easily disappear
because of the absence of humanitarian assistance and basic means of survival. For instance,
in 2024, Yemeni authorities launched a joint military campaign aimed at curbing human
smuggling and trafficking operations along the coast of the Governorate of Lahj. The
deportation practices employed as part of that campaign resulted in individuals being returned
to unknown locations, without adequate basic assistance and protection measures, thereby
exposing them to greater risk of going missing.58
32.
Collaboration between States whose interception practices have reportedly been
incompliant with international maritime and human rights law under externalization policies
that seek to deter migrants from approaching international borders, thereby denying them
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
8
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, art. 98; International Convention on Maritime
Search and Rescue, annex, chap. 2.1.10; and International Convention for the Safety of Human Life at
Sea, chap. V, regulation 33 (1).
International Convention on Maritime Search and Rescue, annex 2.1.3.
A/72/335, para. 11; and A/HRC/36/39/Add.2, para. 80.
A/HRC/45/9, para. 17.
See submission by Fundación para la Justicia y el Estado Democrático de Derecho.
See https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2023/02/italy-proposed-new-sea-rescue-law-puts-morelives-risk-turk; and A/HRC/WG.6/34/ITA/2, para. 62.
See communication GBR 11/2021 and Government reply of 8 April 2022. All communications
mentioned in the present report and responses thereto are available at
https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMSearch/TMdocuments); and https://www.ohchr.org/en/pressreleases/2022/03/un-rights-chief-urges-revisions-uk-borders-bill.
Submission by UNHCR; see also Mixed Migration Centre, “Necessity rather than trust: Smuggling
dynamics on the Eastern Route through Yemen” (December 2024).