Although in many cases indigenous peoples
are also numerical minorities, in some countries
they constitute large majorities of the population despite their relatively low political power.
In some regions, indigenous peoples reject the
‘minority label’ altogether because it does not fit
the numerical reality, their self-perception or the
status they seek in society at large.
Any groups that self-identify both as minorities
and indigenous peoples, and fit relevant objective criteria, could claim rights of both groups.
The highest standard of rights will apply.
Figure 1. Intersecting identities for
minority groups
MIGRANTS
ETHNIC,
RELIGIOUS AND
LINGUISITIC
MINORITIES
INDIGENOUS
PEOPLES
REFUGEES
Key Messages
Some minority groups are also
indigenous peoples
Such groups may claim both minority
rights and indigenous rights but the
highest human rights standards will
always apply
The UNDG Guidelines on Indigenous
Peoples’ Issues and the UNDP Policy of
Engagement with Indigenous Peoples
(2001) may be applied when working
with indigenous peoples.
2.5 DIVERSITY WITHIN
MINORITY GROUPS:
Minorities are not internally homogenous
communities. Several groups may be marginalised within minority communities including
women, children, the elderly, persons with disabilities, sexual minorities and persons living with
HIV. These groups will experience multiple forms
of exclusion and intersecting discrimination.
In some cases, discrimination against these
groups may be culturally entrenched. The exercise of minority rights is not a justification for
the practice of discrimination and the rights of
such groups must be respected fully and equally.
According to the UN Human Rights Committee,
“none of the rights protected under article 27
of the [ICCPR] may be legitimately exercised in
a manner or to an extent inconsistent with the
other provisions of the [ICCPR]”.8
It is important to recall that individuals have the
right not to self-identify with a minority group
to avoid discrimination. For some, internal discrimination within the minority community
may involuntarily push them out. For others, the
social stigma and discrimination that comes with
being a minority may prompt them to disassociate from this community. In the latter case, it
is important to respect the right of self-identification of the individual while simultaneously
working against social and political factors that
devalue the minority identity.
Women and girls from minority groups
experience multiple and intersectional forms
of discrimination based on both their minority
status and their gender. Such multidimensional
discrimination may make them particularly
vulnerable to violations and a denial of their
rights in both public and private life. Minority
women often find themselves marginalised
and face exclusion within their own communities and in the society alike. They might have
Human Rights Committee, General Comment 23, The rights of minorities (Article 27) , UN Doc. CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.5 (8 April 1994): paragraph 8.
8
Chapter 2: Conceptual Issues
13