A/HRC/23/46
of migrants at the border, including practices which infringe their liberty and security, and
detention regimes on both sides of the border that fail to adequately respect minimum
human rights standards. Furthermore, even before crossing the border to the European
Union, whether by sea or by land, migrants are often exposed to serious risks of abuse and
exploitation en route, including by smugglers. This is particularly true for women and girls
who wait in transit countries and who may be exposed to sexually based violence.
21.
The Special Rapporteur further observes that irregular migration took on a particular
meaning in the aftermath of the Arab Spring. In particular, in the summer of 2011, there
were some significant movements of migrants across the Mediterranean to Italy. The arrival
of these boats, however, appears to have been a unique event and the Arab Spring, over the
longer term, has not produced any significant inflow of new migrants to Europe.
Nevertheless, the events sparked heated debate in Europe about management of irregular
migration movements.
22.
Within this context, the Special Rapporteur notes the unique position of the
European Union with regard to management of the complex phenomenon of a common
migration system. The European Union is a singular economic, social and political
partnership among 27 Member States, many of whom have developed domestic legal
traditions with strong human rights protections. In addition, at the regional level, the
European Union has developed a comprehensive system of legislation, with strong human
rights protections that complement domestic fundamental rights law and international
human rights law. Thanks to this system, long-term third-country nationals legally staying
in European Union Member States enjoy similar rights to those of European Union citizens
with regard to free movement, establishment and work conditions. The Special Rapporteur
thus notes that the European Union is uniquely placed to address human rights of migrants
regarding management of its borders.
23.
The strengths of the regional system also bring with them their own challenges. The
Special Rapporteur also recognizes that member States are still largely driven by the strong
influence of domestic public opinion, which is easily swayed against migration. This
attitude to migration policy, which often does not include a human rights perspective, is
then often replicated at the regional level, given the important role of the Council, and
hence in member States, in developing European migration policy and legislation. In
addition, the Special Rapporteur notes that the complex interplay between European Union
and national competence in the field of migration is often exploited, which often means that
human rights slip through the gaps: member States advocate for opaque policies at the
regional level, then use those standards to enable the implementation of more restrictive
domestic policies with regards to migration, and subsequently seek to attribute this to the
regional system. This can perhaps be highlighted by the fact that while the Commission’s
original proposal for the European Union Return Directive set six months as the maximum
period of detention it was, at the insistence of the Council, extended to up to 18 months in
exceptional cases, following which both Italy and Greece increased their maximum length
of detention in accordance with the maximum standard allowed by the directive. It is hoped
that the new ordinary legislative procedure with regard to migration may assist in avoiding
the politicization of migration at the legislative level.
24.
The Special Rapporteur also observes that another corollary of the common
European Union border management system is that those member States geographically
situated at the external border of the European Union free movement (Schengen) area, find
themselves not only responsible for the management of their national borders, but also
custodians of the external border of the entire European Union, which often encompasses
large tracts of land or sea frontiers. The Special Rapporteur notes that the European Union
has acknowledged the magnitude of this task for individual border States, and established
Frontex to assist them with the challenging task of border management. Nevertheless there
7