Second Statement
We wish to highlight the importance of the last parts of the draft recommendations on the content of
education and in particular human rights education for all, minorities and majorities, and education of
the entire population on other cultures and on preserving cultural diversity.
A few days ago we celebrated the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Article 1 of the Declaration states that „All human be ings are born fre e and e qual in dignity and
rights.” Yet in a country like France, equality means uniformity and the notion of equal dignity is often
forgotten. After all, dignity refers directly to the respect for the cultural identity of persons and groups
to which they belong, since the UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity affirms that
„the de fe nce of cultural dive rsity is an e thical impe rative , inse parable from re spe ct for
human dignity”. EBLULFrance mentioned in its report to the Committee on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights in 2007 the unfortunate example of an official school textbook for geography edited in
2003 and distributed in second year classes of secondary education in France, where populations at the
periphery of the state, such as Alsatians, Basques, Bretons, Catalans, Corsicans, Savoyards, are
incredibly portrayed on a map of France and in texts as being at „risk of ide ntitarian closure ”. This
is far removed from reality, for if such risk of an identitarian closure does exist, it is rather to be found
among monolingual French speaker. In such stigmatised regions, autochtonous language speakers are
at least bilingual, often trilingual or even quadrilingual when they are able to attend the all too few
schools in regional languages. On the contrary, their multilingual and pluricultural education prepares
them to embrace cultural diversity beyond state borders, improves their school results and contributes
to their integration in today’s world.
Thus, a tremendous amount of work should be done to develop human rights education and the
understanding of the variety of languages, cultures and history, in particular the regional and
transnational ones which are often ignored in official curricula. The spirit of tolerance and intercultural
exchanges should equally be promoted.
The very notion of minority has also been questioned several times during these debates. A population
may well be a numerical minority a given state, its members may still resent being referred to as a
"minority" , given the possible derogatory connotations. As has already been said, we might talk of
„diverse components” of society on equal terms. We might also talk of dominated people or population,
for minorities may be a majority in numerical terms, while a dominant minority group may hold most
power. In France, 90% of those who graduated from ENA (National School of Administration) and
control the state apparatus were born in Paris. And as we saw, French Academy members