A/HRC/40/53/Add.1
Rapporteur underscores that the Government has a responsibility to safeguard the religious
freedom of all, and not to protect any religion – or any interpretation of that religion – per
se, and that freedom of religion or belief also includes the right not to profess any religion
and to change one’s religion or belief.
19.
The Special Rapporteur notes that particular challenges arise in light of Malaysia’s
plural legal systems, including civil courts, Syariah Courts and indigenous customary
courts. The Syariah Courts only apply to those deemed Muslims. They have jurisdiction in
matters such as marriage, inheritance, adoption and “apostasy”, and have a particular
impact on the human rights, including the cultural rights, of women and children. In
addressing women’s equal cultural rights, the former Special Rapporteur emphasized that
legal pluralism could be problematic when communal or tribal courts or elders are
authorized to apply “traditional” values, norms and practices.4 However, she also noted that
some “fairer balance between gender equality and recognizing cultural and religious
identities” was possible in systems that allowed recourse to constitutional challenge of
traditional authorities, or that ensured that any such plural systems could not justify or enact
dehumanization, violations of dignity or injuries to the physical or mental well-being of
women.5
20.
Malaysia aligned its tenth and eleventh development plans with the Sustainable
Development Goals. Of particular interest for the visit, because of their relationship with
the realization of cultural rights, were the commitments to reach Goal 4 on inclusive and
equitable education, Goal 5 on gender equality, Goal 10 on reducing inequality, Goal 11 on
resilient and sustainable cities and Goal 16 on an inclusive society and the rule of law. The
Special Rapporteur encourages the Government to make clearer the essential role of
cultural rights in development and in the eradication of poverty, as well as in building
social cohesion and mutual respect and understanding. 6
21.
Although article 8 of the Constitution proclaims equality before the law of all
persons and the Government aims to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development objective of leaving no one behind, Malaysia has not ratified the Convention
relating to the Status of Refugees, of 1951, nor has it enacted any laws or regulations
concerning the status of asylum seekers and refugees in the country, leaving this part of the
population highly vulnerable.
C.
General context
22.
Malaysia has developed as a multi-ethnic society comprised of diverse ethnic,
linguistic and religious groups. Apart from the largest groups, of Malays, Chinese and
Indians, Malaysia is home to a number of minorities and indigenous peoples, including the
Negrito, the Senoi and the Proto-Malay in Peninsular Malaysia (generally referred to as
Orang Asli), the Kadazan Dusun, the Bajau and the Murut mainly in Sabah, and the Iban,
the Bidayuh, the Melanau and the Orang Ulu predominantly in Sarawak. Malaysia is also a
multi-religious society, with a population comprised of approximately 60 per cent Muslims,
20 per cent Buddhists, 9 per cent Christians, 6 per cent Hindu and others. One of
Malaysia’s strengths in the past has been the conscious efforts to capitalize on the diversity
and creativity of its people to build the nation.
23.
There are over 130 languages spoken in the country, the vast majority of them being
indigenous languages. Malay is recognized as the sole official language, however public
primary schooling is provided in Mandarin, in Tamil and in some of the major indigenous
languages such as Semai in Peninsular Malaysia, Iban in Sarawak, and Dusun and Kadazan
in Sabah.
24.
Since the 1969 Kuala Lumpur riots which led to a two-year state of emergency and
suspension of the Parliament, one declared goal of the Government has been to defuse
4
5
6
A/67/287, para. 52.
Ibid., para. 53.
A/HRC/14/36, para. 3.
5