A/51/301
English
Page 15
Moroccan origin. Compared to the total number of acts of racist violence,
those against North Africans have reached the unprecedented level of
70 per cent;
"(3) The tendency to see xenophobic opinions as a part of everyday
life is spreading to more and more levels of society." 9/
28. There are also immigration-related problems in Switzerland, where the
Commission fédérale contre le racisme has recently submitted to the Federal
Council a report on the Swiss policy on migration. The report analyses the
"three circles model" adopted by the Federal Council in 1991 to regulate the
recruitment of foreign labour. 10/ Within the inner, or first circle, which
includes citizens of the European Union and the European Free Trade Association,
the movement of labour is completely free; and in the middle (second) circle,
which currently comprises the United States of America, Canada, Australia and
New Zealand, and to which the States of Central and Eastern Europe may later be
added, a limited number of people may be recruited. Theoretically, there can be
no recruitment in the outer (third) circle, comprising "the rest of the world",
except for special cases involving highly qualified specialists.
29. The distinctions are based on criteria of geography, culture, national
politics and economics. The Commission has expressed reservations concerning
the arguments which have been used to make the distinction between the second
and third circles, particularly the "culture gap" argument. Referring to the
positions taken on various occasions by the Federal Council, the Commission has
noted that "persons from the third circle are considered incapable of becoming
integrated, and therefore undesirable, because they do not belong to the same
culture broadly characterized by European ideas". The Commission considers that
"the three circles model is basically racist. The arbitrary division of the
world into concentric circles centred upon Switzerland is ethnocentric and
Eurocentric. The categories introduced in the three circles model define people
by their origin. The model creates new social realities which have negative and
discriminatory effects upon part of the population living in Switzerland. This
contravenes the purposes of the International Convention on the Elimination of
All Forms of Racial Discrimination, offends against human dignity and, all in
all, is a threat to civil peace in our country." 10/
30. The Commission further considers that "the division of the world into close
and distant groups, those who can or cannot become integrated, which has been
established by the authorities and is constantly cited by the general public,
and the resulting construction of an image of the alien, the ’Other’", has
symbolic effects which are harmful. The Commission recalls that "all recent
scientific studies concerning the issue of ethnic and cultural otherness
emphasize the influence of dominant discourse, such as that of State
institutions, on the formation of groups, the hardening of boundaries and the
escalation of conflicts." 10/
31. The situation of migrants in the United States of America also merits
consideration by the General Assembly. The problems occur when migrants cross
the frontier between the United States of America and Mexico. There has been "a
mobilization against foreigners unprecedented since the second world war", 11/
particularly in California. The situation is due to the "illegal" entry of
/...