E/CN.4/2006/78
page 21
guarantee the rights of the indigenous peoples. The existence of human rights commissions or
ombudsmen is not enough if the ministries with responsibilities in sensitive areas for the
indigenous peoples do not take coordinated action.
87.
One of the clearest illustrations of the “implementation gap” is to be found in the public
administration. With a few exceptions, the State bureaucracy reacts slowly to new legislation in
favour of indigenous rights; it is not functionally prepared to address the new challenges; it exists
in an administrative culture that makes it difficult to welcome and accept multiculturalism and
the right to be different; it advocates a heritage of assimilation that rejects recognition of the
indigenous peoples; and it often displays discriminatory, not to say racist, behaviour on
indigenous issues within its own administration. This has been extensively documented in the
areas of the administration of justice, education, health, environmental policy, agrarian issues
and economic development.
88.
Another problem lies in the lack of consultation and participation mechanisms,
established jointly with the indigenous peoples so as to envisage the needs and views of both
parties in order to determine the way in which such mechanisms will be applied in the various
areas: legislative, administrative, development and natural resources programmes, among
others. Unilaterally developed mechanisms ignore one or other of the parties in the consultation,
impose subordination regarding methodology and therefore make for such frustration that the
consultation process is doomed to failure from the outset.
89.
The judicial sector has been increasingly called upon to become involved in this issue.
The courts are instrumental in resolving conflicts between laws, non-enforcement of those laws,
and measures taken by the authorities that are at variance with the reforms and jeopardize the
rights of indigenous peoples and communities. Superior courts, supreme courts and
constitutional courts have played an important role in this process. But they will have to do
much more in the future.
90.
Indigenous people are increasingly availing themselves of international mechanisms for
the defence of their human rights and to try and close the “implementation gap”. At the regional
level the inter-American human rights system has played an increasingly important role and is
beginning to be useful to the African regional system. At the international level the ILO and the
United Nations treaty bodies have unquestionable moral authority that is being increasingly
exercised in defence of the rights of the indigenous peoples, although some States have difficulty
in believing it.
91.
Lastly, the gap can only be closed with full participation of the indigenous organizations
and civil society acting constructively within the framework of national institutions, in the quest
for a solution to conflicts and for consensus which, in the long run, will benefit the national
society as a whole.
92.
The Special Rapporteur trusts that the aspects highlighted in this report can serve as a
guide for Governments in their commitment to more effective implementation of existing
standards on promotion and protection of the rights of indigenous peoples and, accordingly,
makes the following recommendations.