A/HRC/29/36
irregular migration across different member States. Against a backdrop of fiscal and
demographic challenges in many countries and political discourses of austerity, discussing
external migration as a “burden” again legitimizes the further securing of borders and
encourages negative public attitudes. While society undoubtedly has a responsibility
towards migrants and more solidarity in sharing this responsibility is encouraged, migration
in itself is not and should not be presented as a burden. Much economic literature suggests
that, as workers, consumers and taxpayers, migrants contribute to the economic growth of
societies with very limited downsides. In fact, the perceived burden of migration comes
predominantly from the financial, technological and human resources necessary to
implement the European Union’s counterproductive security-focused policies and deal with
their unintended (although foreseeable) secondary effects. Acknowledging that migrants are
human beings with rights, the European Union and its member States should be talking
about sharing a responsibility, not a burden.
75.
The normative basis for more positive, realistic views of migrants sits within an
abundance of fact-based analysis, as well as the European Union’s founding values of
respect for human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law and human rights
for all, as evidenced in the robust human rights regime and the international human rights
instruments that member States have ratified.
Banking on mobility over a generation
76.
Applying the European Union’s core values to policies that are based on fact rather
than fiction leads to migration policies that facilitate mobility and celebrate diversity. The
long-term development of the human rights-based framework discussed above will become
increasingly vital to the Union’s internal and external interests. Over the next 25 years,
Europe will undergo large-scale demographic, societal and labour market changes.
77.
By 2025, more than 20 per cent of European Union citizens will be over 65 years of
age, with a particular increase in those over 85. The population of elderly people will
almost double, from 87.5 million in 2010 to 152.6 million in 2060. It is also expected that
the share of those aged 80 and over will rise from 5 to 12 per cent.5 At the same time, many
member States have fertility rates below the rate of replacement. An average fertility rate of
2.1 children per woman is estimated to be necessary to keep the population at a stable size
between generations in developed countries. United Nations population data suggests that
between 2010 and 2015 all European Union countries will have had average fertility rates
below the 2.1 mark with the regional average being 1.6.
78.
In line with these demographic changes, the European work force is declining. In
2010, for the first time, more workers were retiring from the European labour market than
were joining it. The European Union and OECD are predicting that, with a zero net increase
in migration, the working age population will drop by 3.5 per cent by 2020. Over the next
50 years, the working-age population is expected to decline by nearly 42 million.6
79.
These changes have the potential to exacerbate and widen existing skills gaps within
the European Union. Of the companies that responded to the 2013 European Company
Survey, 40 per cent stated that, despite high unemployment levels, they found it difficult to
find applicants with the correct skills set. The demographic shifts discussed above are going
to add pressure and impetus to the need to ensure balance between labour supply and
demand. According to both the European Union and OECD, for the European Union to
5
6
European Commission, Population Ageing in Europe, Facts, Implications and Policies (2014).
Ibid. See also OECD and European Union, “Migration Policy Briefing” (2014).
15