A/HRC/62/55/Add.1
Ethnic origin is included within article 1 of the International Convention on the Elimination
of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, as one of the grounds for racial discrimination. Race
is also included within article 1 as a separate ground. The Special Rapporteur is of the opinion
that conflating race and ethnicity is not aligned with the definition of racial discrimination
included within that Convention. Difficulties defining and acknowledging race as grounds
for racial discrimination risk limiting opportunities for racial self-identification and rendering
invisible the harmful process of racialization. The Special Rapporteur further noted that
difficulties defining and acknowledging race can lead to the use of proxies, including those
that have the potential to inadvertently reinforce harmful racial stereotypes and hierarchies.
For example, she noted that it is common and socially acceptable to refer to a “migrant
background” to describe people perceived as being from marginalized racial and ethnic
groups, whereas white people tended to be described as having an “Austrian background”.
This appeared to take place irrespective of whether those belonging to marginalized racial
and ethnic groups had been born in Austria.
14.
In addition to sensitivities with the use of the term “race”, the Special Rapporteur
noted interrelated issues with defining “racism”. She noted that the use of different proxy
terms to define “race” seems to be contributing to a lack of shared understanding of what
constitutes racism and racial discrimination, including systemic, structural and intersectional
forms of such phenomena. This absence of a shared understanding is exacerbated by the
absence of an overarching definition within the relevant legal and policy framework. Not
having an overarching definition of racism and racial discrimination risks leaving gaps in
corresponding protections and a degree of “invisibilization” of these harmful phenomena
within broader society. This further contributes to the systemic erasure of the historical
realities of discrimination faced by racially and ethnically marginalized groups.
15.
The Special Rapporteur stresses the importance of developing a comprehensive and
shared definition of racism and racial discrimination that includes the process of racialization
that is inherent to racism and racial discrimination, in a manner that is appropriate within the
national context. Such a definition should also capture intersectional, systemic and structural
forms of racism and racial discrimination.
3.
An absence of special measures to further racial equality
16.
A significant gap in the anti-racial discrimination legal framework is the absence of
the enshrinement of special measures to advance substantive racial equality. Special
measures, often referred to as “affirmative action” or “positive measures”, are targeted
benefits provided to underrepresented or marginalized racial and ethnic groups, aimed at
ensuring equitable representation and the equal enjoyment of human rights by all. Pursuant
to article 1 (4) of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
Discrimination, State Parties are obligated to develop and implement special measures
wherever there is disparate enjoyment of human rights by persons and groups. Given the
persistent systemic inequalities experienced by groups, including Roma persons, people of
African descent, Muslims and people of Arab descent, it is important that Austria consider
the development of formal special measures.
17.
The Special Rapporteur received many reports that, in the absence of special
measures, marginalized racial and ethnic groups remain underrepresented in employment,
education and political participation, contributing to the continuation of racial inequality. For
example, parliamentarians reported that racial representation is very limited in Parliament
and that those from marginalized groups feel poorly represented within this key
decision-making forum. The Special Rapporteur also heard multiple reports that there are a
limited number of people from marginalized racial and ethnic groups working in the
Government, including roles that involve working directly on addressing racial
discrimination. She took note of efforts to ensure diversity and inclusion through the diversity
management system, including by public sector employers and universities. Nevertheless,
she urges Austria to consider taking comprehensive special measures, in line with its
obligations as a State Party to the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms
of Racial Discrimination, to better ensure racial representation across society and to advance
substantive racial equality.
5