A/HRC/22/49/Add.1
41.
Roma cite poverty and their poor socio-economic conditions, exacerbated by the
general economic decline, as significant factors in falling enrolment levels. Roma
representatives emphasized that the costs of education are restrictive and that assistance in
the form of free transport to school, school meals and scholarships are essential and should
form part of a revised education action plan. Despite Government assurances that free
textbooks are available to Roma, representatives of Roma in Kakanj stated that free books
had not been made available to them.
42.
Government and school representatives acknowledged challenges and deficiencies
on the part of authorities to ensure that Roma children attend school according to legal
requirements. However they emphasized that problems also stem from within communities
themselves, traditional practices such as early marriage, and a lack of importance being
attributed to education, especially for Roma girls. UNICEF surveys have found the
incidence of early marriage of Roma girls to be 48 per cent.
43.
Roma in Banja Luka described more positive experiences in education, reporting
that most children attend school and that the high drop-out levels common in other
localities are not the case for their community. They described good cooperation with
school principals, who call parents when a child does not attend school. They noted efforts
to promote the value of education within the community. Nevertheless, few people in the
community work and it was acknowledged that improved educational outcomes are not yet
leading to improved opportunities for formal employment.
44.
Some positive examples in enrolment and attendance of Roma children provide
evidence that progress is possible where dedicated attention and targeted policies and
programmes are in place. However, these positive examples are in marked contrast to the
experiences in some other localities. Roma representatives and international bodies
informed the Independent Expert that in some localities, including Bijeljina and Mostar,
attempts to increase Roma school attendance have largely failed and levels are extremely
low.
45.
Roma children are likely to be more motivated to attend class if they have Roma
teachers and assistants, but a lack of Roma teachers has been identified and is indicative of
a wider problem that negatively affects Roma education. Roma lack opportunities to learn
or receive instruction in Romani languages. For example, staff at the Fifth Primary School
in Brčko District, which has an ethnic mix of teachers, reported that although their pupils
included 54 Roma children, no Roma teacher had been found for the school. School staff
noted that a further 36 Roma children had dropped out. In Banja Luka, Roma requested a
Romani language teacher and received a positive response, however no teacher could be
identified.
46.
Additional concerns require investigation by competent authorities. Roma are
disproportionately represented in schools for children with special educational needs. Some
Roma parents reportedly place their children in these schools not on the basis of identified
learning disability, but rather on the basis of social factors, perceiving them to offer a more
welcoming environment as more Roma children attend. Allegations were also made that
some mainstream schools enrol Roma children as required but fail to provide them with the
levels of teaching and attention provided to other children.
B.
Employment and social protection
47.
Surveys and reports by national bodies, such as the Directorate for Economic
Planning, and international organizations, such as Human Rights Watch, consistently
12