Second Minority Forum (12-13 November 2009)
Statement by Norbert Tóth, independent expert on minority rights
Statement delivered under agenda item V. National practices and real experiences: existing
mechanisms providing for the political participation of minorities
Madame Chair of the Forum, Madam High Commissioner Madam Independent Expert on Minority
Issues, Distinguished Delegates, honourable colleagues, Ladies and Gentlemen,
First of all allow me to express my appreciation and gratitude towards all of you including particularly the
United Nations itself who consider the welfare of minorities as a remarkably important and necessary
precondition of democracy. As István Bibó a Hungarian philosopher once stated 'being a democrat means
not to be afraid of those who have different opinions, speak different languages, or belong to other races.'
As our current item of the agenda is the so-called national practises and real experiences I would briefly
summarize the existing practices of Hungary as a state regarding to the issues of minorities. According to
the relevant provisions of our present constitution “The national and ethnic minorities living in the
Republic of Hungary participate in the sovereign power of the people: they represent a constituent
part of the State.” furthermore “ The laws of the Republic of Hungary shall ensure representation
for the national and ethnic minorities living within the country.” and “ National and ethnic
minorities shall have the right to form local and national bodies for self-government.”
Based on the constitutional provisions mentioned a Law on the rights of national and ethnic minorities was
adopted in 1993 and there are some other laws, decrees and regulations especially on the elections and
composition of minority self-governments as well. Hungary worked out a sort of cultural autonomy by this
acts and the Law on Minority Rights recognizes not only the individual but the collective rights of minorities.
In addition the State created some special authorities and institutions in order to guarantee the protection of
minority rights. For instance an ombudsman for minority rights was elected and an Equal Treatment
Authority was established both by the Hungarian parliament. These institutions play a key-role in protecting
the rights of minorities and promoting the principles of equality and non-discrimination.
The Law on Minorities recognizes 13 different minority groups living in Hungary. All the minorities and the
persons belonging to a minority group have the right to form their self-governments at local, territorial and
national levels. The relationship between the state (including the system of self-governments) and the
minority self-governments are based on the democratic principles of partnership and cooperation.
The core-elements of the self-governance of minorities in Hungary are – amongst others - the following.
Firstly, the question of identity that is whether someone belongs to a given minority community or not,
solely depends on the individual's choice. Secondly the practice of the rights of minority self-governments is
protected by the independent judiciary system of the State. In addition anyone is freely allowed to use his
or her native language at all levels of public life without any kind of restrictions. Finally the financial needs
necessary to manage the minority self-governments and also the political, economical, and cultural
institutions of minorities are funded by different actors including the State budget itself, the budget of local
and territorial self-governments and other resources for instance external donations and own revenues. The