A/HRC/34/50/Add.1
23.
Nevertheless, members of the Jewish community of Denmark also expressed
concerns and a general feeling that the space for their religious practice has been shrinking
in recent years. One example is the ban on ritual slaughter without prior stunning of the
animal, enacted in February 2014. In practice, this does not prevent Jews from having
access to kosher meat, since anyone can still import it from other countries; the same is true
for Muslims who import halal meat. However, the ban may put at risk their right to practise
their religion when it comes to dietary requirements, as other countries might follow in the
prohibition of ritual slaughter without prior stunning of the animal.
24.
By far, the biggest worry articulated by representatives of the Jewish Community of
Denmark however stems from public demands for outlawing religiously-motivated
circumcision of male infants. Those who brought up this concern are afraid that the
increasing social hostility towards the practice is putting growing pressure on members of
Parliament to impose a legal ban. Worldwide, no State currently forbids this practice in
general, and the likelihood that Denmark would actually take such a step seems somewhat
remote. However, public demands to outlaw the circumcision of boys have already greatly
changed the societal atmosphere. According to opinion polls, a broad majority of the
Danish population would favour a ban on circumcision of underage boys, and organizations
of medical doctors in Denmark, child rights organizations and the non-governmental
organization “Intact” have been very vocal in demanding legislative action in this direction.
For most of the religiously practising Jews and Muslims, this would have far-reaching
consequences. While Muslims, too, widely practise male circumcision and see it as an
essential part of their religious identity, the significance for Jews may be even higher.
Although there has always been discussion also within the Jewish community itself, and
although some Jewish parents — usually non-religious, “secularized” Jews — decide
against circumcising their boys, the overwhelming majority of religiously practising Jews
worldwide understand the circumcision of newborn boys as a cornerstone of Jewish
identity. Through the practice of circumcision, they see themselves in continuity with their
forefathers throughout three millenniums. This is by far the predominant view shared by
religious Jews across the various orthodox, conservative and liberal currents within
Judaism. For many Jews, a formal ban of circumcision would signal no less that they
cannot stay in that country.
25.
The effect of the current discussion is very much felt, especially in social media,
which can assume an extremely aggressive tone. One member of the Jewish community of
Denmark told the Special Rapporteur that he and his wife were currently expecting another
child. When it became clear that it would be a girl, they felt very relieved since this would
spare them “questioning looks”. This example illustrates that public calls for prohibiting
circumcision, apart from the question of whether a ban will ever become reality, have
already had an impact on the Jewish community of Denmark. This is similarly true for
Muslims in Denmark, who also struggle with many other challenges.
26.
The issue of circumcision is complex and has many medical, psychological, cultural
and religious facets. Controversies exist concerning all these different aspects of the
phenomenon. Within the human rights community, too, the circumcision of underage boys
has led to an ongoing polarization. It is natural that the issue also becomes a topic of public
debate in any democratic country where circumcision is practised, not only in Denmark.
However, it is all the more important that those engaging in public debate be aware of the
sensitive character of the theme and how deeply it affects many Jews and Muslims in their
religious identities.
27.
Another topic raised by the Jewish Community of Denmark is the increasing
hostility that Jews experience whenever the situation in the Middle East escalates, such as
during the Gaza crisis in the summer of 2014. This is an issue that certainly warrants
attention, in order for the Jewish community to further feel safe and at home in Denmark. It
8