Statement by Dr Corinne Lennox
School of Advanced Study, University of London
Forum on Minority Issues
Item 1. Review: Normative frameworks and the mainstreaming of the Declaration at the UN
On the 30th anniversary of the Declaration, it is clear that the UN system has failed minorities. The
mechanisms for the protection of minorities are among the weakest in all of international human
rights law. The UN dedicated space and funding for minorities is less than 10% of what is offered for
indigenous peoples.
Reform is needed in two areas: 1) a legally-binding treaty and; 2) more effective monitoring and
coordination mechanisms.
First, there have been protections for minorities developed across many different treaties and
declarations, and there is a case for consolidating these in a single treaty. Minorities are the last
major group lacking any global, legally binding treaty for comprehensive protection.
Second, the UN needs a space dedicated to the ‘coordination of activities related to minorities
within the UN system’ and better participation of minorities in ‘providing expert advice and
recommendations on minority right issues’.1
The Forum on Minority Issues needs to be reformed to better align with related institutions such as
the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues and the Permanent Forum on People of African Descent.
The structure of the Forum should change, to include oversight of a larger panel of members,
including representatives from minority groups, and expanding the number of days. The UN
agencies in the UN Network on Racial Discrimination and Protection of Minorities could each report
annually to the Forum, as they do to the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues. The Forum could
rotate between Geneva and New York to ensure that minority rights are included in the human
rights, development and peace and security work of the UN.2 A UN Year or UN Decade on
minorities could stimulate better coordination.
Finally, the UN Secretary-General should appoint a High Level Panel3 to recommend a series of
reforms to achieve rights protection, better UN coordination and a stronger voice for minority
groups.
1
Adapted from the Mandate of the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues.
The Permanent Forum on People of African Descent is mandated to rotate between Geneva and New York.
See General Assembly Resolution 75/314, Establishment of the Permanent Forum of People of African Descent
(6 August 2021): para. 6.
3
See, for example, the High-Level Panel on Internal Displacement https://www.un.org/internal-displacementpanel/; High-Level Panel on Digital Cooperation https://www.un.org/en/sg-digital-cooperation-panel; and High
Level Expert Group on Net-Zero Emissions: https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/high-level-expert-group as
possible models.
2