A/HRC/13/40/Add.1
one within their jurisdiction is deprived of the right to life, liberty or security of person
because of religion or belief and that no one is subjected to torture or other cruel, inhuman
or degrading treatment or punishment, or arbitrary arrest or detention on that account and to
bring to justice all perpetrators of violations of these rights” (para. 9 b). The Special
Procedures mandate holders asked the Government to indicate the legal basis for the arrest
and detention of the abovementioned persons and how these measures were compatible with
applicable international human rights norms and standards as stipulated, inter alia, in the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights.
(b)
Response from the Government dated 16 November 2009
241. In its response dated 16 November 2009, the Government indicated that the
investigative department of the Shakhrikhansky district internal affairs office in
Andizhanskaya province instituted criminal proceedings on 20 May 2009 for an offence
punishable under article 244-2, part 1, of the Criminal Code of Uzbekistan. The preliminary
investigation established that from 2000 to 2009 Mr. Rasulzhon Abdurakhimovich
Rakhmatov, Mr. Isroil Pulatovich Usmonov, Mr. Utkirbek Nazarbekov and others were
active members of an extremist religious group whose aim was to commit criminal acts in
Uzbekistan in order to overthrow the constitutional order and organize underground
“jamoat” cells. According to the Government, they brought “jamoat” members together and
instructed them, using prohibited literature and recordings of broadcasts by the leader of the
Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan, Takhir Yuldashev, to unconstitutionally overthrow the
Government. Reportedly, they trained people in methods of taking over power and
removing the legally elected and appointed Government representatives, they
unconstitutionally violated the country’s territorial integrity and they distributed materials
with the same content as that mentioned above.
242. The Government indicated that Mr. Rasulzhon Abdurakhimovich Rakhmatov and
other associates were prosecuted in a criminal case under article 242, part 1; article 159, part
3 (a) and (b); article 2441, part 3 (a) and (c); article 2442, part 1; article 243; article 246,
part 1; article 189, part 3; article 190, part 2 (b); and article 223, part 2 (b) of the Criminal
Code of Uzbekistan. The accused were the subject of a pre-trial restraining order in the form
of detention that was issued by the criminal court in the town of Andizhana. On 24 May
2009, the decision was made to initiate the investigation of Mr. Rasulzhon
Abdurakhimovich Rakhmatov. According to the Government, from the moment of their
arrest the constitutional rights of the accused persons were fully respected. They were
provided with State legal aid, and in accordance with article 217 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure of Uzbekistan, their relatives were informed of their arrest in a timely manner.
243. On 26 August 2009, a criminal indictment of Mr. I. Usmonov and others, issued in
accordance with article 388 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, was sent to the procurator’s
office of Andizhanskaya province. On 3 September 2009, the indictment was approved and
the case was sent to court. The criminal case against Mr. I. Usmonov and others began on
25 September 2009. The judicial proceedings in the criminal case against I. Usmonov and
others are continuing.
244. The Government indicated that during the consideration of this criminal case, no
instances have been found of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment of the
defendants. It emphasized that all the defendants had been provided with defence counsel,
and during the judicial hearings their interests had been defended by 14 lawyers.
245. In addition, the Government confirmed that criminal proceedings had been instituted
against Mr. Pulatzhon Usmonov under article 223, part 2 (b), of the Criminal Code of
Uzbekistan. However, in the course of the preliminary investigation, a decision issued on 28
August 2008 by the Senate of the Majlisi Oli declared an amnesty in connection with the
57