A/HRC/4/21/Add.1
page 29
matched organs would suggest the existence of a computerized matching system for transplants
and a large bank of live prospective donors.
110. It is alleged that the discrepancy between available organs and numbers from identifiable
sources is explained by organs harvested from Falun Gong practitioners, and that the rise in
transplants from 2000 coincides and correlates with the beginning of the persecution of these
persons.
111. On organ transplants, in general, it has been reported that in March 2006, legislation was
introduced which bans the sale of human organs and requires the donor to give written
permission. The legislation also limits transplants to certain institutions, which must verify the
source of the organs. This law came in force on 1 July 2006. Contrary to the Government
assertion that human organs have been prohibited from sale, in accordance with the 1991 WHO
guiding principles, it has been reported that up to this time Chinese law has allowed the buying
and selling of organs, has not required that donors give written permission for their organs to be
transplanted, there has been no restriction on the institutions which could engage in organ
harvesting or transplants, there was no requirement that the institutions engaged in transplants
had to verify that the organs being transplanted were from legal sources, and there was no
obligation to have transplant ethics committees approve all transplants in advance. Moreover,
evidence exists, for example, that at least up until April 2006 price lists for organ transplants in
China were published on the Internet.
Response from the Government dated 28 November 2006
112. The Government replied that in March 2006, Falun Gong began fabricating the so-called
“Sujiatun Concentration Camp” issue, saying that 6,000 Falun Gong practitioners had been
incarcerated in Sujiatun Hospital in Shenyang, Liaoyang Province and that two thirds of them had
had organs removed from their living bodies and the corpses cremated to destroy the evidence. In
order to clarify the facts, the Sujiatun District Government carried out an investigation at the
hospital; domestic and foreign media including Japan’s NHK and Hong Kong’s Phoenix Satellite
Network and Ta Kung Pao conducted on-the-scene interviews; and two visits were paid by
consular personnel from the US embassy. Based on the results of these investigations it was
discovered that the hospital only had 300 beds and was completely incapable of housing more
than 6,000 persons. There was no such basement for incarcerating Falun Gong practitioners, as
alleged by Falun Gong. The so-called “cremation oven” announced by Falun Gong is in fact a
boiler/furnace room, whose primary function is to provide heat and disinfect medical instruments.
This boiler room has several transparent glass windows and a lawn outside that is open to the
public where nearby residents come daily to stroll. In such a place, with such a physical setting,
there is simply no way to cremate corpses in secret, continuously, and in large volume. The
rumors fabricated by Falun Gong collapse on their own. Everyone recognizes that Sujiatun
Hospital is nothing but a simple hospital and that there is no evidence to show that it is being
used for any purpose other than as a public hospital. This once again proves that the “Sujiatun
Concentration Camp” fabricated by Falun Gong is nothing more than a rumor.
113. As a WHO member-state, the Chinese Government resolutely abides by the WHO’s 1991
Guiding Principles on Human Organ Transplants and strictly forbids the sale of human organs.
Human organ donation must be done voluntarily and with the written consent of the donor.