A/HRC/58/49/Add.1
intolerance, including hate crimes and online hate speech directed at religion or belief and
racial minorities, and other vulnerable groups; discrimination and social exclusion faced by
Roma; and regression in the promotion of gender equality; as did Hungary’s third UPR
(November 2021).
IV. National laws, policies, institutions and practices
15.
Hungary’s Fundamental Law (Constitution), adopted in 2011, guarantees the right to
freely choose, change, and practice religion, and to engage in religious ceremonies both
publicly and privately (Article VII(1)). The law explicitly prohibits discrimination based on
religion. Hungary’s legal system criminalizes any speech that aims to violate the dignity of
religious communities or incites hatred against them, with punishments from fines to
imprisonment for incitement to violence, threats, hate speech, or the public denial of
historical atrocities like the Holocaust. The Penal Code declares anyone who “publicly
denies, casts doubt on, trivializes, or attempts to justify the fact of genocide or other acts
against humanity committed by the National Socialist or Communist regimes” as being guilty
of a felony (article 333).
16.
The ‘National Avowal’ at the beginning of the Constitution states that ‘[w]e recognise
the role of Christianity in preserving nationhood. We value the various religious traditions of
our country’. Christianity is referenced several times in the Constitution. Although the
Fundamental Law asserts the historical role of Christianity in shaping the nation, it maintains
the principle of the autonomy of ‘Churches’ (used to refer to all religious organisations). The
State cooperates closely with Churches in the provision of education, health, child protection
and other social institutions. (Article VII.(4)).
17.
Hungary’s 2011 Church Law (Act CCVI) marked a major shift in the country’s prior
legal approach to religion or belief organizations since 1990. Previously, any group of
citizens could establish a religious organization and some 350 religious or belief groups were
recognised. The 2011 law narrowed the scope and parameters of legal personality for
religious or belief communities. As a result, it stripped the majority of legal status, reducing
those officially recognized to 14, and later 32 organizations - others need a majority vote in
Parliament to be recognised. This received much criticism, including from this mandate, 3 and
resulted in litigation, including at the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). There are
currently 32 established Churches, 16 registered Churches and 260 religious associations
recognised in four tiers (see para. 30).
18.
The 2014 ECtHR case Magyar Keresztény Mennonita Egyház and Others v. Hungary
held that deregistration of the applicants as churches had led to violations of article 11
(freedom of association) read in light of article 9 (freedom of thought, conscience and
religion); and unfairly discriminated against certain religious groups by denying them access
to state benefits and public funding.
19.
In response to both domestic and international criticism, the Hungarian government
amended the Church Law in 2018. Amendments took effect in 2019, allowing religious
organizations to determine their own internal structures, and permitting all such organizations
to receive 1% of voluntary tax donations from the public and a further 1% from voluntary
tax donations to charitable institutions and civil society. However, the amendments fell short
of addressing the broader discrimination concerns.
20.
Hungary does not have a national human rights action plan or strategy, but its principal
related action plans focus on social inclusion, poverty reduction, women, children, and the
environment. There has been a distinct shift from a gender equality framing to one
emphasising traditional family structures and the child-bearing role of women. The
‘Empowering Women in the Family and Society Action Plan (2021-2030)’ replaced the
‘National Strategy for the Promotion of Gender Equality 2010-2021’; and the ‘National
Social Inclusion Strategy 2030’, adopted in 2021, highlights poverty alleviation, reduction of
3
4
HUN 2/2011.