A/HRC/7/19/Add.4
page 21
fight all forms of discrimination. In this regard, it offers an important degree of protection to
potential victims of racism and discrimination, as well as providing opportunities for them to
redress violations in different realms. The Law on National Minorities is also an important legal
tool and a progressive instrument due to its formal recognition of the cultural autonomy of
minority communities as well as its explicit embrace of multiculturalism, rather than
assimilation, as the official State policy regarding integration.
75. Alongside its overarching legislation, Lithuania has managed to establish institutions that
are well placed to provide effective remedies to racism and discrimination. The Special
Rapporteur was particularly impressed by the quality of the work performed by the
Ombudspersons on Equal Opportunities and Children’s Rights in attempting to correct and
prevent violations of the Law on Equal Treatment. He also recognizes the awareness and
vigilance of the Office of the Prosecutor General concerning new challenges that are emerging in
the fight against racism in Lithuania, particularly regarding new migrants, and its proactive
policy to initiate investigations of racist crimes and incitement to racial and religious hatred.
76. Apart from institutions operating on the legal realm, the Special Rapporteur was also
encouraged by the work of other government bodies that focus on social and cultural policies
towards vulnerable groups. In particular, he wants to highlight the central role played by the
Department of National Minorities and its director to protect and promote the cultural traditions
of national minorities. Despite the limited amount of funding, it has managed to develop creative
and innovative policies to address the needs of minorities and promote multiculturalism, being
clearly recognized by minority communities as a legitimate interlocutor. The Ministries of
Education and Culture, in the Special Rapporteur’s view, also show a positive and creative
contribution to the promotion of multiculturalism. It is especially relevant to highlight the
Ministry of Culture’s activities in the realm of Vilnius’s selection as the European “Capital of
Culture” in 2009, when a number of events to illustrate Lithuania’s diversity will be organized.
77. However, despite the existence of a progressive legal and institutional framework, there are
still a few protection gaps that need to be corrected through the adoption of complementary
legislation or amendments. In particular, a number of civil society interlocutors have pointed out
that various cases of racist aggressions tend to be viewed by law enforcement agencies as acts of
hooliganism or vandalism, thus disqualifying the racial motivation. This worrisome tendency to
equate racial attacks with hooliganism was also noted by the Special Rapporteur in his meetings
with a few State authorities, including the President of the Supreme Court. In order to correct
this legal gap, and in line with recommendations made by other international bodies, it is
important for Lithuania to amend its criminal code in order to recognize racism as an aggravating
circumstance in racist crimes. Such a measure would help law enforcement agencies bring
perpetrators to justice and act as an important legal deterrent for future aggressions.
78. A second frequently mentioned problem with the existing legal framework regards the full
application of its provisions. Human rights NGOs and representatives of minorities pointed out
cases where existing laws have not been fully applied or enforced. The most common example
that was mentioned concerned instances that would characterize as incitement to racial hatred.
Despite a clear constitutional prohibition of incitement to racial hatred, in practice very few cases
have been brought to justice or they led to light punishment, often an administrative fine. The
challenges in effectively prosecuting cases of hate speech, in particular the issues of intent and
burden of proof as well as the question of the balance between freedom of expression and the full