E/CN.4/1989/44
paqe 10
"Paragraph 45 of the report states that in Tibet ... Buddhist
monasteries could not use freely the donations they have received. That
is not true. In Tibet ...» Buddhist monasteries practise a democratic
manaqement system. The monasteries are qoverned and manaqed by lamas
residing in them. In accordance with the reliqious customs, ...
donations and contributions to temples from believers are manaqed and
used entirely by the temples themselves, mainly for the purposes of
maintaininq the temples and subsidizinq the livinq expenses of the
monks. Government departments in charqe of reliqious affairs never
intervene in these matters.
"In paraqraph 46, the report says that, in China, Buddhist monks in
Tibet are desiqnated by a Government Committee and bishops of the
Catholic Church are appointed by the Chinese authorities who do not
recoqnize the Vatican hierarchy. This is totally contradictory to the
facts.
"The Constitution ••• stipulates in explicit terms that citizens
have the freedom of reliqious belief. In Tibet ... requests to become
lamas, purely internal affairs of the reliqious circles, are considered
and decided upon by the temple in accordance with reliqious requlations.
There is no such thinq as desiqnatinq lamas by a qovernment committee.
The appointment of bishops of the Catholic Church of my country is, in
exactly the same way, decided by the Church itself and the qovernment
authorities never intervene in it.
"As for the non-recoqnition of the Vatican hierarchy, this is the
choice of the Church ... out of its own wish to administer the Church
independently. The Catholic and Christian Churches of China pursue the
principle of 'self-administration, self-support and self-propaqation',
free from domination by foreiqn forces. This in no way contravenes the
principle of freedom of reliqious belief.
"Paraqraph 51 of the report mentions that the Chinese authorities do
not authorize reliqious instruction. In my country, the principle of
separation between education and reliqion is applied. Schools for
general education do not have a reliqious curriculum. If the parents
desire, however, they are fully entitled to impart reliqious knowledqe to
their children in the family. The Government does not prohibit such
reliqious instruction."
35. In a communication of 21 July 1988 addressed to the Government concerned,
the followinq information was transmitted by the Special Rapporteur:
"It has been reported that, althouqh some measure of freedom of
worship has been qranted in Tibet durinq the past few years and Tibetans
have been allowed to reconstruct a few monasteries, such freedom chiefly
embraces an area of ritualistic practices. The real practices of
Buddhism, like studyinq and propaqatinq the teachinq of Buddha, are
reportedly subject to various restrictions. A few examples of such
restrictions reportedly include the confiscation of belonqinqs of the
abbot of a conqreqation in Konqpo Bonri, the refusal to authorize the
monks of Drayab Bo-qhon in east Tibet to establish a Buddhist school o£