E/CN.4/1989/44
paqe 19
"It is alleqed that a number of Assyrian churches and monasteries
have been destroyed. Two relatively recent cases were alleqedly the
demolition in 1984 of Abbasaraf Yun church, located in the villaqe of
Badaliyah in the Semele reqion, and the occupation and demolition in 1985
of Mar Zaya Cathedral, the main church of the Assyrian Church of the
East, located in the Baqhdad district of Karadad Maryam."
Ireland
45. In a communication of 21 July 1988 addressed to the Government concerned,
the followinq information was transmitted by the Special Rapporteur:
"It has been alleqed that althouqh constitutional quarantees, such
as those contained in article 44.2.2 of the Irish Constitution, state
that 'the State quarantees not to endow any reliqion' and article 44.2.3
states that 'the State shall not impose any disabilities or make any
discrimination on the qround of religious profession, belief or status',
and althouqh the churches in Ireland formally favour the separation of
Church and State, certain developments, in particular in the education
and health sectors, would appear, in fact, to infrinqe upon those
constitutional riqhts.
"It has been reported that there is a monopoly of the supply of
publicly-funded primary and elementary schoolinq (1 per cent run by the
State or local authorities; the remainder essentially denominational,
and for the most part under the patronage of Roman Catholic Bishops) and
a monopoly in the training and supply of primary schoolteachers under the
control of Roman Catholic and Church of Ireland Bishops.
"It has been alleqed that the interweavinq of reliqious instruction
with secular education as advocated by the Roman Catholic hierarchy and
the Department of Education leads to an effective denial of the exercise
of the constitutionally-quaranteed riqht of parents to send their children
to any school which is publicly funded without having them receive
reliqious instruction.
"It has been reported that all primary schoolteachers, who have no
option other than to seek admittance to denominational traininq colleqes,
are selected on reliqious criteria in addition to academic entry
requirements.
"It has been alleqed that the hospitals, 99 per cent of which are
publicly funded, are Church-controlled; that the personal autonomy of
hospital professional staff is constrained by religious criteria; that
trainee nurses, although paid out of the Exchequer, are being selected on
the basis of religious conformity; and that a medical ethics code
determined by the Catholic hierarchy inroostinstances binds both nursing
and medical staff throuqh their contract of employment, despite the fact
that they receive their salaries directly from the Department of Health."
46. On 9 December 1988, the Permanent Mission of Ireland communicated the
reply of the Irish authorities to the Special Rapporteur's letter of
21 July 1988, in the form of two comments concerninq, respectively,
information on the education sector and on the health sector.