A/HRC/24/41/Add.3
(k)
Karen, Hmong, Lahu, Mien of Thailand, commonly known as ethnic
minorities and officially referred to as “chao khao” or “hill tribes”, and the nomadic sea
gypsies or “Chao Lay”; and
(l)
Tay, Thai, Hmong, Muong and Khmer of Viet Nam, officially referred to as
ethnic minorities (dan toc thieu so, dan toc it nguoi).
8.
Today these groups are among the most discriminated against, socially and
economically marginalized, and politically subordinated parts of the societies of the
countries in which they live. Regardless of the controversy around issues of definition and
categorization, it is apparent that political actors in Asia agree that there is a need to address
the human rights issues facing these distinct peoples, which are issues very similar to those
faced by groups unquestionably recognized as indigenous peoples in other parts of the
world, and which fall within the sphere of the current international concern for the rights of
these peoples.
9.
It is worth noting that all of the countries addressed in the consultation supported the
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples when it was adopted by
the General Assembly in 2007, with the exception of Bangladesh, which abstained from the
vote on the Declaration. Although not espousing a fixed definition of the term
“indigenous”, the specific relevance of the Declaration, as evident by its terms, and of the
various United Nations programmes and mechanisms concerning indigenous peoples,
including the mandate of the Special Rapporteur, is to those groups indigenous to a territory
that are in non-dominant positions, and that have suffered and continue to suffer threats to
their distinct identities and basic human rights in ways not felt by dominant sectors of
society.
10.
In adopting the Declaration, State Members of the United Nations manifested their
support for the Declaration’s call for affirmative and concerted measures to address the
disadvantaged conditions of indigenous peoples in accordance with the human rights
principles elaborated upon in that instrument. The Special Rapporteur does not question
that the Declaration applies to disadvantaged indigenous peoples in Asia, as it does to
indigenous peoples elsewhere.
III. Overview of human rights issues raised during consultation
A.
1.
Securing rights to lands and resources in the context of extractive
activities
Recognition and protection of land and resources rights
11.
A principal concern expressed by the participants at the consultation is the lack of
adequate regulatory protections for indigenous peoples’ customary rights over land,
territories and resources. In many countries throughout the region, there is no specific
legislation that recognizes indigenous peoples’ customary land tenure. Even in those States
where the regulatory frameworks afford such recognition, significant challenges remain to
secure those rights in practice. Implementation of land laws has been found wanting, with
slow land demarcation rates and formal procedures that place a heavy burden of proof on
indigenous communities to demonstrate ownership.
12.
In addition, despite notable jurisprudence in a few Asian countries recognizing the
rights of indigenous groups to their customary lands, the gazetting of indigenous lands has
been slow and fraught with problems. Some Governments have continued to challenge
court decisions recognizing pre-existing rights to customary lands. Misrepresentation of
6