The existence of a minority is not, and should not be always numerical. Even when the minority—as is
usual—is a numerical one, we must tackle statistics cautiously. An ethnic, religious or linguistic group
may prove to be a minority in the State as a whole, yet a majority in some districts. To give a case in
point, The Turkish minority in Western Thrace, Greece, has an estimated population of 150.000, does
comprise 1.3% of the general population (2001 census) and it constitutes majority in Rhodope (52%)
and almost half of the population in Xanthi(45%).
There is an officially recognized Muslim minority of 140.000 to 150.000 members reside in Thrace
(Western Thrace) and the status of the Minority is determined by the Treaty of Lausanne in 1923.
Although the Treaty of Lausanne does not specifically mention the ethnic identity of the Muslim minority
in Western Thrace, there is a specific reference to the Turkish ethnic identity of the Mus lim
Minority in Western Thrace in legal and international documents. "Etabli Documents" which were the
documents given to the people of Greek and Turkish origin who were left out of the exchange procedure
in accordance with the provisions of the Agreement on the Exchange of Turkish and Greek Populations
on 30 January 1923 mentioned the ethnic origin of Muslim minority in Western Thrace as Turkish.
Greece haS, on various occasions, stated that all Greek citizens, including the members. of the "Muslim
minority in Thrace" have the right for individual self-identification and underlined that the Muslim
minority is defined by its religious identity, not ethnic or national minority. Greece does not subscribe to
the right of any group to self-identification on a collective basis and the right of as sembly or association
of the group which seeks to determine their identity. Although so-called other segments within the
Minority are recognized and even welcomed and supported by Greek authorities, the Turks are not
allowed to use their right of self-identification, while the existence in a country of ethnic minorities is
defined on the basis of collective rights. On 18 February 2009, the report of the Independent Expert on
Minority Issues, Gay McDougall, following her mission to Greece on 8-16 September 2008, stated that
The absence of formal recognition by the state of a particular societal group as constituting "a minority"
is not conclusive", and continued that "Rather, the existence of a group to which a state owes minority
protections is a matter of objective facts and exercise of the right of self-identification by persons
belonging to the group". The independent expert urged Greece to protect the right to self-identification
and the freedoms of expression and association of minority communities.' CERD similarly took note of
the explanation by Greece for recognition of a single minority only and called upon Greece to ensure the
non-discriminatory implementation, for all groups within the scope of the Convention, of the rights
referred to in article 5 of the Convention.'
In the twentieth anniversary of the Declaration, States should respect the right to self-identification of
the persons belonging to national or ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities and retreat from the dispute
over how to identify national or ethnic, religious and linguistic groups and place their full focus on
protecting the rights to self-identification of those communities.
We recall Recommendation 14 that all countries should reaffirm their commitment to the principles
contained in the Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and
Linguistic Minorities, and publicize it widely.
We fully support para. 20, in which it is recommended that Governments have the primary responsibility
for implementing the Declaration and other minority rights standards and instruments, and that States
should recognize explicitly the diversity within their respective societies, including with respect to race,
ethnicity, religion and language. States should demonstrate their commitment to the
1
2
A/HRC/10/11/Adc1.3, p. 2, and paras. 83, 88 and 90.
CERD/C/GRC/CO/16-19, para. 8.
2