A/54/386
the Panorama Galatsiou region, contested by the Orthodox
Church and the Old Calendarists’, the competent Greek
authorities have concluded that what seems like an act of
religious extremism in the information received by the
Special Rapporteur is in reality a civil law controversy,
upon which the competent Courts of Justice have
undertaken and, as acts liable to punishment have taken
place meanwhile, the case is pending before justice”.
22. India. Violence against Christians, notably in
Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Orissa, Punjab and
Maharashtra states, is reportedly continuing in the form
of attacks on places of worship, property, churchgoers and
clergy. This situation remains unchanged despite the
assurances of the country’s highest authorities.
23. Indonesia. It is reported that, in December 1998 in
Jakarta at the beginning of Ramadan, approximately one
thousand Muslims attacked Catholic and Protestant places
of worship as well as a Catholic school. It seems that these
incidents were finally halted by the police and the army.
In November 1998, sectarian clashes allegedly resulted in
the deaths of 13 Christians and the destruction of churches
and mosques. These events are said to have occurred in
part because of religious extremism affecting the Muslim
and Christian communities.
24. Iraq. The urgent appeal sent to Iraq concerned the
assassination of Ayatollah Mohammad Sadeck al-Sadr and
his two sons and the subsequent demonstrations by Shiites
in the suburbs of Baghdad, and in Kerbala and Nassiriya.
This appeal also drew attention to allegations of repression
by the armed forces (25 persons assassinated and 250
injured in Baghdad).
25. The Government of Iraq replied that it was committed
to guaranteeing the freedom of its various communities and
religions and the security of their national and religious
symbols, in accordance with the rights and guarantees of
the Constitution and the national legislation. It added that
the guaranteeing of the security of all Iraqi citizens was the
responsibility of the Iraqi State and its people. It
emphasized that the murder of Ayatollah Mohammad
Sadeck al-Sadr was a great loss for Iraq since he had been
a great imam and an authority on Islam, devoted to
education, prayer, national unity and the fight against
forces hostile to Iraq. In particular, he had called for a
jihad against the imperialist forces that were oppressing
the Iraqi people by means of an economic blockade and air
strikes. It stated that those making accusations against Iraq
without waiting for the results of the investigation under
way were the same persons who had accused the Iraqi
Government of imposing Ayatollah Mohammad Sadeck
al-Sadr as a religious leader. The Government asked how
its Government can be accused of the murder of this
dignitary when he had condemned the allies of the United
States of America and the United Kingdom of Great Britain
and Northern Ireland, who, styling themselves the “Iraqi
opposition”, were seeking the financial support of the
American Administration for the purpose of sowing
discord in Iraq. The United States and its allies should be
the subject of the accusations. The allegations of
demonstrations and arrests were disputed. The Government
stated that Arab and foreign news services that had visited
the areas concerned had reported that the situation was
calm and normal, and said that it would transmit the
results of the investigation under way. The Special
Rapporteur is awaiting with interest the outcome of this
investigation.
26. Israel. Ultra-orthodox Jews are said to be creating a
climate of intolerance in Israel. In November 1998, in
Kiryat Malachi, an American couple engaged in
humanitarian work with Ethiopian immigrants was
allegedly attacked by young ultra-orthodox Jews who
suspected them of proselytizing. In the town of Beersheba
(Negev), one thousand ultra-orthodox Jews (haredim),
acting on a rumour spread in the synagogues alleging that
the Messianic Jews intended to baptize Jewish children, are
reported to have laid siege to the place of worship rented
by the Messianic Jews. The police apparently guarded the
building in order to maintain order, but subsequently told
the leaders of the congregation that they must protect the
area themselves. A chief rabbi from Beersheba spoke on
television and in the newspapers of his opposition to the
messianic group and its activities. It would seem that this
person is in fact the brother of a member of the Knesset
who supported a draft law banning religious conversion
(E/CN.4/1998/6). In Mea Shearim, ultra-orthodox Jews
allegedly attacked the residence of three Swiss Christians,
whom they accused of proselytizing. Despite the absence
of any reply by Israel, the Special Rapporteur wishes to
recall the responsibility of the State in the fight against
intolerance and discrimination, in this instance in respect
of freedom of religion.
27. Nepal. It is alleged that, in November 1998, in
Rukum, the police executed two Christian leaders of the
Taka Church, whom they suspected of belonging to the
Maoist organization waging a civil war in remote areas of
Nepal. It would appear that the Christian community is in
fact subjected to pressure by Maoists hostile to their
religious practices, by the police, who execute Christians
suspected of being Maoists, and by Hindu militants of the
Bharatiya Janata Party, who target Christians.
5