A/HRC/11/36/Add.3
page 17
anecdotal accounts of victims of racial profiling in stop and search operations by the police
were heard, including a testimony by an African American Member of Congress victim of such
an incident.
54. Several organizations expressed concern at the National Special Entry-Exit Registration
Program (NSEERS), put in place in 2002. The special registration program required male
non-citizens over the age of 16 and from 25 countries to register with local immigration
authorities. Twenty-four of these countries have a majority Muslim population.32 While the
initial requirements of re-registration after 30-days and one year of continuous presence in the
United States have been suspended,33 the program continues to be considered by civil society as
discriminatory on the basis of national origin and religious background.
55. Civil society organizations expressed criticisms regarding recent attempts to address the
issue. The Guidance Regarding the Use of Race by Federal Law Enforcement Agencies issued
by the Department of Justice was criticized, particular because it “does not cover profiling based
on religion, religious appearance or national origin; does not apply to local law enforcement
agencies; does not include any enforcement mechanism; does not require data collection; does
not specify any punishment for federal officers who disregard it; contains a blanket exception for
cases of ‘threat to national security and other catastrophic events’ and ‘in enforcing laws and
protecting the integrity of the Nations’ borders’”.34
B. Hate crimes
56. Interlocutors highlighted that the main weakness of federal hate crimes legislation is the
dual requirement that needs to be met for the Federal Government to be able to investigate and
prosecute a case: bias-motivated violence and relation to a federally protected activity. In cases
that do not meet these requirements, the jurisdiction lies at the state level. However, many states
lack the capacity and resources to thoroughly investigate and prosecute such crimes. In this
regard, a Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act designed to strengthen the role of
the Federal Government in the investigation and prosecution of such crimes and to expand the
grounds for protection was approved in the House of Representatives and the Senate in 2007.
However, it was withdrawn after an expression by the White House that the President would
veto the bill, which was seen as “unnecessary and constitutionally questionable”.35
32
The 25 countries are Afghanistan, Algeria, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Egypt, Eritrea, Indonesia,
Iran (Islamic Republic of), Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, the Libyan Arab Jamahirya, Morocco,
Oman, North Korea, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, the Sudan, Syrian Arab Republic,
Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates and Yemen.
33
See press release by the Department of Homeland Security, “NSEERS 30-Day and Annual
Interview Requirements to be Suspended”, available at http://www.dhs.gov/xnews/releases/
press_release_0306.shtm.
34
Amnesty International. Threat and Humiliation.
35
http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/legislative/sap/110-1/hr1592sap-h.pdf.