A/77/549
21. In South Asia, Indigenous peoples and those subject to caste-based
discrimination face environmental devastation from development projects over which
they have limited free, prior and informed consent. In Indonesia, the legacy of
colonial-era racist urban planning, combined with excessive ground water extraction
and pro-capital adaptive responses, subjects low-income residents of Kampungs in
Jakarta to flooding and to the threat of forced displacement. 39 Throughout South-East
Asia, rampant industrial activity has transferred the harms of environmental
degradation and toxic waste from industrial hotspots in the global North to non-white
communities in the global South. 40
22. A number of submissions highlighted the prevalence of racial sacrifice zones in
the United States. 41 For example, “Cancer Alley” is a petrochemical corridor along
the Mississippi River, where 150 petrochemical facilities operate. With a
predominantly African American population, it is a region with the highest rates of
multiple forms of cancers in the United States. Racist legacies loom large over Cancer
Alley. It was originally called Plantation Country, a place where enslaved Africans
were forced to labour. New facilities like the “Sunshine Project” stretch over at least
four ancestral burial grounds and are concentrated in the Fifth District, whose
residents are 86.3 per cent African American. The land use plan for the District has
been changed from “residential” to “residential/future industrial” without notice,
allowing for one of the largest plastics facilities to be approved. By contrast, chemical
companies are barred from constructing new facilities in the Third District, whose
residents are 78.4 per cent white. 42
23. A 1987 study revealed a nationwide pattern, with racially marginalized
communities in the United States five times more likely than white communities to
live near toxic waste. 43 As noted in a submission, these disparities cannot be explained
solely on the basis of income inequality: an in-depth study in 2008 found that Black
people in the United States with an annual household income o f $50,000 to $60,000
live in neighbourhoods subject to greater pollution than the average white people with
household incomes under 10,000 dollars. 44
24. In one submission it was reported that, in Canada, the Aamjiwnaang First Nation
is surrounded by Sarnia, Ontario’s so-called “Chemical Valley”. Residents experience
low air quality and high rates of negative health outcomes, such as miscarriages,
childhood asthma and cancer. 45
25. Throughout Europe, Roma communities are forced to live n ear hazardous waste
sites or in areas that are prone to climate change-related disasters, often to make way
for industrial development or tourism. At the same time, Irish Travellers often lack
access to culturally specific accommodation and are denied reli able access to water,
__________________
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
8/24
Michelle Kooy and Karen Bakker, “Splintered networks: the colonial and contemporary waters
of Jakarta”, Geoforum, vol. 39, No. 6 (November 2008); Jeroen Frank Warner and Hanne Wiegel,
“Displacement induced by climate change adaptation: the case of ‘climate buffer’ infrastructure”,
Sustainability, vol. 13, No. 16 (August 2021); and Kian Goh, “Urban waterscapes: the hydro politics of flooding in a sinking city”, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,
vol. 43, No. 2 (March 2019).
Benedetta Cotta, “What goes around, comes around? Access and allocation problems in Global
North-South waste trade”, International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and
Economics, vol. 20 (2020).
Submissions from Ms. Shirley and Heinrich Böll Foundation.
See submission from Human Rights Advocacy Project; and communication No. JAL USA
33/2020.
United Church of Christ, “Toxic wastes and race in the United States: a national report on the
racial and socio-economic characteristics of communities with hazardous waste sites”, 1987.
Liam Downey and Brian Hawkins, “Race, income, and environmental inequality in the Unite d
States”, Sociological Perspectives, vol. 51, No. 4 (December 2008).
See submission from Maat for Peace, Development and Human Rights; and A/HRC/49/53.
22-24043