CCPR/C/135/D/3624/2019
authors reliant on expensive imported goods, which they often cannot afford. Seasonal and
wind patterns play a key role in ensuring the authors’ livelihoods and subsistence, but are no
longer predictable. Precipitation, temperature and monsoon seasons have been subject to
change, making it harder for the authors to pass on their traditional ecological knowledge.
Seagrass beds and dependent species have disappeared. While crayfish is a fundamental
source of food and income for the authors, they no longer find crayfish in areas where coral
bleaching has occurred.
2.6
Referring to the Torres Strait Regional Authority report, the authors predict that the
severe impacts on their traditional ways of life, subsistence and culturally important living
resources will present significant social, cultural and economic challenges, have effects on
infrastructure, housing, land-based food production systems and marine industries, and cause
health-related problems such as an increased incidence of disease and heat-related illness.
2.7
The State party has failed to implement an adaptation programme to ensure the longterm habitability of the islands. Despite numerous requests for assistance and funding made
to the State and federal authorities by or on behalf of the islanders, the State party has not
responded promptly or adequately. Although some works were carried out on Boigu and
Poruma between 2017 and 2018, many of the priority actions identified in the Torres Strait
regional adaptation and resilience plan 2016–2021 remain unfunded. At present, no further
government funding has been confirmed. Local authorities have taken a triage approach to
saving homes and infrastructure, while residents of Warraber and Masig have taken matters
into their own hands, using green waste and debris to secure fragile coastal ecosystems from
erosion.
2.8
The State party has failed to mitigate the impact of climate change. In 2017, the State
party’s per capita greenhouse gas emissions were the second highest in the world. Those
emissions increased by 30.72 per cent between 1990 and 2016. The State party ranked fortythird among 45 developed countries in reducing its greenhouse gas emissions during that
period. Since 1990, the State party has actively pursued policies that have increased
emissions by promoting the extraction and use of fossil fuels, in particular thermal coal for
electricity generation.
2.9
There are no available or effective domestic remedies to enforce the rights of Torres
Strait islanders under articles 2, 6, 17, 24 and 27 of the Covenant. The authors’ rights under
the Covenant are not protected in the Constitution or any other legislation applicable to the
federal Government. The High Court of Australia has ruled that State organs do not owe a
duty of care for failing to regulate environmental harm.6
Complaint
3.1
The authors claim that the State party has violated their rights under articles 2, read
alone and in conjunction with articles 6, 17 and 27; and articles 6, 17 and 27, each read alone.
They also claim violations of the rights of their children identified above under article 24 (1),
read alone and in conjunction with articles 6, 17 and 27 of the Covenant. The State party has
failed to adopt adaptation measures (infrastructure to protect the lives of the authors and their
way of life, homes and culture against the impacts of climate change, especially sea-level
rise). The State party has also failed to adopt mitigation measures to reduce greenhouse gas
emissions and stop the promotion of fossil fuel extraction and use. As indicated in the
Committee’s general comment No. 36 (2018) on the right to life (para. 62), climate change
is a matter of fundamental human rights.
3.2
The State party’s obligations under international climate change treaties constitute
part of the overarching system that is relevant to the examination of its violations under the
Covenant.7
6
7
High Court of Australia, Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v. Ryan, 2002.
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, art. 31.
3