E/CN.4/2006/73
page 13
59.
In addition, certain particularities of some host countries’ immigration policies and
practices that can render migrants especially vulnerable to abuse have also been highlighted.
Such policies and practices include the confiscation of a migrant’s identity documents by
employers, sometimes with the apparent complicity of government officials who confiscate such
documents at the time of entry and hand them over to employers; the existence of “sponsorship”
systems where migrants are not allowed to change employers so that the legality of their stay in a
specific country depends entirely on these employers; lack of monitoring of places of work and
private recruitment agencies; placing certain categories of migrants such as domestic migrant
workers outside the protection of the law; and lack of support for migrants wishing to complain
of abuse. Particular difficulties in instantiating and pursuing legal action are faced by migrants
who have returned to their home countries.
60.
As far as sending countries are concerned, the adoption of comprehensive programmes of
protection for their migrant nationals is an important development. Such action is often carried
out by various government ministries and agencies and often through a country’s consular
services. The issue of protection in general and, more specifically, that of consular protection is
a theme that also deserves further consideration and examination as such practices can provide
important examples and guidance to Governments seeking to protect migrants from violations
and abuse.
61.
In situations of both regular and irregular migration, legal or practical restrictions on
migrants’ participation in unions are a key factor in abuses suffered in the labour market. For
this reason, this is a fundamental issue that was highlighted by the Special Rapporteur in his
report to the General Assembly.
62.
Likewise, discrimination and anti-migrant ideology, which can be evidenced by the
existence of racist crimes, police profiling, reports in the media and declarations by political
figures, is a factor that affects all migrants, whether they be regular or irregular, temporary or
permanent. Finally, as with other human rights violations, impunity for abuses is one of the
principal elements in the persistence of human rights violations.
2. Underlying factors and specific situations
63.
In order to adopt effective action against violations of migrants’ human rights, it is
essential to consider the different aspects of existing violations, including the underlying factors
leading to such violations. Today, many of the problems of migration take place in the private
sphere, so that the State is responsible for a failure to act in legislating and enforcing the law.
Thus, the actions of smugglers and traffickers, of private employment agencies and of abusive
employers are primarily attributable to private individuals or companies, though the State retains
responsibility for lack of due diligence in enforcing the rights of migrants. Moreover, in cases
concerning particularly vulnerable persons, such as children, the State has additional obligations
to ensure protection.
64.
Nevertheless, the State is directly responsible for many difficult and sensitive issues
linked to migration, such as action taken by State agents in the course of border control, arrest,
detention and guaranteeing fair hearings; trial procedures for migrants, whether in administrative