A/HRC/15/37/Add.2
Under sections 77–79 of the Constitution of 1966, eight chiefs from each of the eight major
Tswana tribes — the Bamangwato, Batawana, Bakgatla, Bakwena, Bangwaketse,
Bamalete, Barolong and Batlokwa — were guaranteed a seat on the House of Chiefs, while
representatives of the numerous other, non-dominant tribes competed for the remaining
seven seats in elections for the then 15-member body. Further, the Chieftainship Act of
1933 defined “chief” and “tribe” by reference to the eight dominant Tswana tribes only.
11.
The Constitution was amended in 2007 to revise the composition of the House of
Chiefs, now known as the Ntlo ya Dikgosi. Additionally, after the Botswana High Court
declared the Chieftainship Act unconstitutional for its discriminatory characteristics,2 that
act was repealed and replaced by the Bogosi Act of 2008, which established a more tribally
neutral framework for recognition of tribes, tribal areas and their respective chiefs. While
the Government has expressed to the Special Rapporteur its position that the constitutional
amendments, together with the Bogosi Act, now afford equal treatment to all tribes and
ensure equitable representation, the Special Rapporteur remains concerned with some
aspects of these reforms, a matter which is addressed in section IV (B) below.
12.
Other laws still recognize Tswana tribes and tribal structures, without similar
recognition of the smaller tribes and their respective political and social structures. For
example, the Tribal Territories Act of 1968, which still provides part of the legal
framework for indigenous land rights in Botswana (see paragraphs 40–44 below), names
tribal territories after the major Tswana tribes. This legislation also named the Tswana
chiefs as the custodians of these territories, though it did not confer ownership rights.
13.
Tribal customary law, primarily based on oral tradition, has been incorporated into
the legal framework of Botswana since independence. Under the Customary Law Act, tribal
customary law is valid to the extent that it “is not incompatible with provisions of any
written law or contrary to morality, humanity or natural justice”. Customary law is
administered by all courts of Botswana, when applicable, in cases involving tribal
members, including by customary courts operating under the authority of chiefs or
headmen. These customary courts derive their authority from oral tradition as well as from
the Customary Courts Act. Customary courts have been developed in connection with the
kgotla system, which is a system for handling matters of concern to the tribe through
community meetings, and which is based on Tswana custom.
14.
Botswana is party to a number of United Nations treaties and to the African Charter
on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Furthermore, it voted in favour of adopting the United
Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Botswana is not a party to the
International Labour Organization Convention concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples in
Independent Countries, 1989 (No. 169), although the Government expressed to the Special
Rapporteur that it supports the general principles and objectives of the Convention.
C.
The application of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of
Indigenous Peoples
15.
In voting in favour of the Declaration, the Government of Botswana has manifested
its support for the Declaration’s call for affirmative and concerted measures to address the
disadvantaged conditions of indigenous peoples in accordance with the human rights
principles elaborated upon in that instrument. At the same time, the Government takes the
position, as reiterated to the Special Rapporteur, that all people of Botswana — with the
exception of some naturalized citizens — are indigenous to the country. However, the
2
6
See Kamanakao I and Others v. The Attorney General & Another [2001] 2 B.L.R. 654.
GE.10-13968