A/HRC/53/26
child and to providing migrants with access to information pertaining to their rights and
obligations during all stages of migration.
C.
Irregularity and human rights
1.
Drivers leading migrants to irregularity
26.
Pathways towards irregular migration are varied. Migrants may fall into situations of
irregularity when entering a country irregularly seeking protection or in search of safety and
dignity or when losing their regular status because of a change in employers and/or restrictive
migration labour policies. In some cases, migrant victims of crime or abusive conduct may
find themselves in an irregular situation when fighting for justice. It is important to
acknowledge that most migrants have little control over the complex factors that define their
migration status. In most cases, they find themselves in an irregular situation through no fault
of their own.
27.
Residence and work permits are often linked to a job contract, which must be regularly
renewed. The implication of such a practice is that migrants can easily lose residence status
following the loss of a job. Not fulfilling administrative requirements to renew residence
status (e.g. due to high financial fees, unclear requirements or ambiguously communicated
deadlines) may also result in migrants falling into irregularity. Other migrants may have their
regular residence status associated with their spouse in cases of marriage or family
reunification, which in some circumstances, such as separation from a violent partner, may
result in the loss of regular residence status. Asylum-seekers who are found not to be in need
of international protection may receive a return decision that may not be enforced
immediately nor long into the future. There may be a variety of reasons for such a situation,
for example a lack of administrative documents needed to enter the country of origin, health
issues, or the best interests of the child. In such a case, authorities may tend to formally or
informally tolerate the asylum-seeker’s stay, although they do not grant residence status. This
leaves asylum-seekers in a protracted legal and social limbo without any long-term
prospects.14
28.
When options for safe and regular pathways for migration are insufficient, some
people may still be compelled to leave their country of origin for reasons of health or survival.
The adverse effects of climate change and environmental degradation; unequal access to
economic and social rights, including health care, decent work, food, land or water; unequal
opportunities, including gender inequality; and gender-based violence can all be compelling
reasons for migrants to move through irregular migration channels. Other drivers or structural
factors include gender-based migration bans, recruitment costs, dishonest labour recruiters,
misleading or false information and a lack of understanding of complex migration rules. 15
29.
Detention, deportation, social exclusion and the denial of migrants’ access to their
rights in the country of destination are also among the reasons that migrants in irregular
situations live in fear for their lives. Undocumented migrants may be detained for several
reasons. Refugees, asylum-seekers and migrants in situations of vulnerability fleeing
violence and war often do not possess the proper documentation. As a consequence, many
migrants and asylum-seekers are questioned and detained for not having valid and regular
forms of identification, despite having pending asylum claims. On the other hand,
impoverished migrants prefer irregular channels for migration, which exacerbates their
vulnerability and exposure to exploitation.16
30.
It should be noted that the intersection between migration and other forms of
discrimination (based on gender, race, ethnicity, religion and sexual orientation) and the false
connection of irregularity to criminalization exacerbate the vulnerability of irregular
migrants. Such exacerbated forms of discrimination, together with the oppression resulting
from the marginalization and criminalization of such migrants, tend to result in the systemic
14
15
16
GE.23-06641
Caritas Europa, “Demystifying the regularisation of undocumented migrants” (2021).
ILO, Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers in Irregular Situations and Addressing Irregular
Labour Migration: A Compendium (2021).
See submission from the Migrant Forum in Asia.
7