A/HRC/24/50
accused. The Court further incorporates more culturally responsive traditional values into
sentencing.32
V. Key areas for advancing the right of indigenous peoples to
access to justice
A.
Advancing access to justice through national courts
32.
At the national and regional levels, strategic litigation, education, outreach and
advocacy can help to expand access to justice and protections for the rights of indigenous
peoples. 33 One example is the Maya Joint Programme in Guatemala, which seeks to
empower indigenous organizations to use litigation to demand recognition of their rights. It
includes training and has focused on cases addressing indigenous rights to lands and
territories; bilingual intercultural education; identity; and the promotion of indigenous
languages. Positive outcomes have included a court ruling restoring the property of 4,185
hectares to the Kaqchikel Maya community of Chuarrancho. The decision provides a legal
basis for recognition of ancestral lands and indigenous forms of organization.
33.
The Working Group on Indigenous Populations of the African Commission on
Human and Peoples’ Rights has noted, in the context of a successful case brought against
the Government of Uganda by the Benet people on eviction from their lands, that successful
litigation helps to expand access points to justice for indigenous peoples and encourages
them to fight for their rights through legal means.34
34.
There is support for the participation of victims in trials at the International Criminal
Court.35 The Expert Mechanism encourages indigenous peoples to pursue this as an option
where relevant, along with the principles of universal jurisdiction.
B.
Issues relating to the rights of indigenous peoples to lands, territories
and resources
35.
The Declaration affirms that States are to establish and implement processes to
recognize and adjudicate the rights of indigenous peoples as related to their lands,
territories and resources (art. 27). The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has held that
States must provide indigenous peoples with an effective and efficient remedy for resolving
claims to their ancestral territories and that failure to do so can amount to violation of the
rights to a fair trial and to effective judicial protection.36
1.
Barriers
36.
Indigenous peoples face difficulties in obtaining adequate access to justice with
respect to their rights as related to lands, territories and resources, especially where these
are or have been claimed by States, private owners, businesses or others. Challenges
include lack of access to legal services and collusion between private sector entities and
32
33
34
35
36
See www.sasklawcourts.ca/index.php/home/provincial-court/cree-court-pc.
Abraham Korir Sing’Oei, at the Human Rights Council panel discussion on access to justice.
See “Report of the African Commission’s Working Group on Indigenous Populations/Communities,
research and information visit to the Republic of Uganda” (2006).
Seminar on access to justice: John Washburn.
See Case of the Indigenous Community Yakye Axa v. Paraguay, judgement of 17 June 2005.
9