E/CN.4/2004/76/Add.2
page 13
had resulted in a decrease in the number of owners; in addition, more migrants had been
travelling in a single boat, with the result that the journeys had become more hazardous. In
Melilla, the Special Rapporteur was informed that 1,200 cases of fraud are detected every year
and that there were problems of corruption within the Moroccan police.
44. The Special Rapporteur suggested to the Minister of the Interior that the first measure that
should be taken is to work to ensure that prospective illegal migrants, in their countries of origin,
do not put their trust in the criminal networks. According to the Minister, if a deportation policy
is not implemented, the migrants will continue to believe what they are told by the “mafias”
because they will see that relatives, friends and acquaintances who have left with the help of the
mafias have remained in Spain. The Minister stressed the need for a coordinated policy vis-à-vis
the countries of origin from which the trafficking networks operate and referred to a proposal
made by the Government of Italy within the European Union to establish quotas for legal
migration by citizens of countries which cooperate in dismantling the trafficking networks.
During her meeting with the Director-General of the Foreigners and Immigration Office, the
Special Rapporteur stressed the need to study in greater depth how these networks operate and to
investigate possible ramifications of the networks in Spain and other European Union countries;
throughout her visit she had only heard from the authorities that the criminal networks came from
African, Latin American or Asian countries.
C. Detention
45. The Special Rapporteur visited a number of detention centres for foreigners (CIEs).
Although the administrative detention of migrants is not of a punitive character, the Special
Rapporteur noted that all the centres visited were old prisons which, because of their structure,
had serious limitations. She visited the El Matorral centre, where 846 migrants were detained. A
number of women whom she interviewed stated that the day of her visit was the first time they
had been allowed to go out into the courtyard, since they normally stayed in their rooms. The
Special Rapporteur noted that health assistance was provided in all the centres, and was told that
that assistance was given in emergency cases and in cases of sickness with very obvious
symptoms. She expresses her concern at the fact that no preventive measures are taken in the case
of infectious and contagious diseases and that there is no monitoring of possible cases of HIV
infection, inter alia.
46. The law ensures that detained immigrants should be given information about administrative
and judicial decisions affecting them in a language they understand in all cases in which they are
detained for breaches of the Aliens Act. Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur noted with concern
that the detained migrants suffer from a serious lack of information, legal assistance and
translation and interpretation services. UNHCR and other organizations expressed concern at the
absence of legal assistance or the unsatisfactory nature of assistance, which makes access to
asylum difficult.
47. She was also informed that in some communities, although detention must be authorized by
the judge, the latter normally confirmed the police proposal without direct contacts with the
migrant or visits to the detention centres. According to the same reports, the officially appointed
lawyers are often not experts in migration. She was also informed of the lack or limited nature of
consular protection.
48. During her visit to La Verneda Centre in Barcelona, the Special Rapporteur interviewed an
undocumented Nigerian woman who told her how she had seen her lawyer only once and knew