A/78/213
priorities. The contribution of this and similar initiatives 59 to the achievement of
development goes far beyond the creation of economic wealth that could be measured
by the salary of the artists and facilitators involved. Avenues need to be found for
such relevant initiatives to be included and accounted for in the international
development apparatus.
D.
International organizations fail to respect cultural rights
59. Since cultural rights are not explicitly addressed nor fully understood, they are
very often disregarded in the work of international development and trade
organizations.
60. The one-size-fits-all economic policies of IMF hinder the enjoyment of the
rights of communities to implement their philosophies and priorities and often have
deep and lasting adverse effects on cultural rights and on the levels of inequality in
the populations of debtor countries. The liberalization policies of IMF have often
required that borrowers privatize the ownership of social service industries. In
sub-Saharan Africa, these policies resulted in increased tuition fees for schools, with
no exemption for poor or vulnerable populations, often leadin g to the exclusion of
women and girls. 60 The IMF Strategy Toward Mainstreaming Gender (2022)
acknowledges widening gender disparities, and that allowing communities to lead
processes could have avoided such effects. 61 In addition, the widespread effects of
IMF conditionality policies disproportionately fall on the cultural sector, which is
often considered a luxury. When investments in institutions are reduced, cultural
institutions are usually the first to be cut. 62
61. In some countries, special economic zones have been promoted by the United
Nations Development Programme, the United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development and the World Bank as effective mechanisms for facilitating economic
growth, despite violations of the cultural rights of concerned populations. 63 It is
reported that some development projects in China that claimed to boost tourism and
local cultural resources have been conducted without consultation with, the free, prior
and informed consent of, or the sharing of the benefits with the populations
concerned, resulting in a commodification of local heritage and a misuse of UNESCO
heritage instruments. 64
62. The World Bank has acknowledged negative impacts on cultural rights in
several projects. For example, a hydroelectrical project fin anced by the World Bank
that severely affected the cultural identity and heritage of the community members
living in Chamoli District, Uttarakhand, in India, has shown the importance of
__________________
59
60
61
62
63
64
23-14310
Contributions from the Dominican Republic; International Organization for Migration; Cox’s
Bazar (Bangladesh); and International Teaching Artist Collaborative.
See Fatma Osman Ibnouf, “Impact of the World Bank and IMF polici es on rural women’s human
rights in Sub-Saharan Africa”, Agenda: Empowering Women for Gender Equity, No. 28 (2008),
p. 32.
IMF, Strategy Toward Mainstreaming Gender, p. 6.
See the contribution of Observatorio Nacional de Derechos Humanos (Bolivaria n Republic of
Venezuela).
See the contribution of Natural Justice and Earthlife Africa (2022). See also Lara Domínguez and
Colin Luoma, “Decolonising conservation policy: how colonial land and conservation ideologies
persist and perpetuate Indigenous injustices at the expense of the environment”, Land, vol. 9,
no. 3 (2020), p. 65.
See the contribution of the International campaign for Tibet. See also Uyghur Human Rights
project, available at https://uhrp.org/report/the-complicity-of-heritage-cultural-heritage-andgenocide-in-the-uyghur-region/.
17/24