E/CN.4/2005/88
page 10
27.
For the same reasons schools, when they do exist, are often in substandard physical
condition, teacher absenteeism is high, the requisite school supplies are not delivered with any
regularity and the use of audiovisual equipment and other modern technology is particularly
difficult (when electricity has not been installed, for example). The supply of educational
services for indigenous children is generally farther below the recommended minimum than is
the case for other sectors of the population.
28.
According to information received by the Special Rapporteur, some 81,000 homes in
certain parts of India (Andra Pradesh, Bihar, Orissa, Rajastan and Bengal) lack access to
education services. In one tribal area in Tripura, for example, many schools lack basic physical
facilities, as they are converted during the rainy season into shelters for livestock; the poor
sanitary conditions in the schools then affect school attendance.1
29.
In Ecuador and Bolivia some indigenous students must travel long distances on foot for
hours, cross rivers and use canoes to attend schools that often lack piped drinking water.
According to the Department of Education in Ecuador’s Cotopaxi Province, 526 rural children
did not go to school in 2003 because the schools were too far away. In Colombia the level of
education on indigenous reservations is reported to be minimal, owing to a lack of infrastructure
and teachers.
30.
In State schools in Ecuador the Government runs a school food programme for
indigenous children, yet a study shows that over 1.3 million pupils do not regularly receive the
breakfasts and lunches provided under the programme.
31.
In the Russian Federation indigenous peoples in the north find their access to schools
restricted by their remote situation, the vast distances and transport difficulties, as well as the
deteriorating school infrastructure. These peoples’ economic problems exist alongside a number
of serious social problems such as unemployment and high rates of alcoholism, suicide and
infant mortality to create an environment in which it is hard to determine what educational
strategy is most appropriate to local conditions.
32.
The documents that the Special Rapporteur consulted also show that public spending on
education for indigenous children is generally lower than for other sectors of the population, that
teachers of indigenous children tend to receive lower pay and incentives than do other teachers
and that their level of preparation is also below average.
33.
In addition, indigenous children also often do not attend school with the same regularity
as other children, even if they have, at least in principle, an opportunity to do so. Sometimes this
is because children are needed by their parents in the field or in the home, especially at certain
times of the year such as harvest time or grazing periods, so that their school attendance is
1
Information concerning many of the cases mentioned in this report comes from the
documentation submitted to the Expert Seminar on Indigenous Education, the report of which is
contained in document E/CN.4/2005/88/Add.4. See also Linda King and Sabine Schielmann,
“El reto de la educación indígena: experiencias y perspectives” [“The challenge of indigenous
education: experience and perspectives”], UNESCO, 2004, Cultural Survival Quarterly, 2004.