A/HRC/15/37/Add.4
management account”. The quarantined funds can only be spent in specially licensed
stores on “priority needs”, such as food, clothing, and household items, using a
bright green “BasicsCard” that clearly identifies its holder as someone subject to
income management. This regime applies to all those living in prescribed areas
inhabited by indigenous peoples, regardless of whether or not they have
responsibilities over children or have been shown to have problems managing
income in the past. By contrast, outside of the prescribed areas, income quarantining
applies only on a case-by-case basis in demonstrated situations of neglect, abuse, or
inadequate school attendance. Further, the NTER terminated the Community
Development Employment Project (“CDEP”), under which the Commonwealth
provided funding to employers to hire Aboriginal peoples who otherwise would
have received unemployment support. Since termination of the CDEP, payments are
now classified as unemployment payments, and are therefore subject to compulsory
income management.5
• The NTER imposes bans on alcohol consumption and pornographic materials within
Aboriginal communities in prescribed areas (with limited exceptions to the alcohol
ban), and in connection with the pornography ban requires policing of the use of
publicly funded computers. Mandatory signs are prominently placed at the entrances
to the communities, announcing the alcohol and pornography bans (“it is an offence
to bring, possess, consume, supply, sell or control liquor in a prescribed area without
a liquor permit or license” and “it is an offense to bring, possess, supply, sell and
transport certain prohibited material in a prescribed area”) and outlining serious
fines, up to AUD 74,800 and/or 18 months in jail for failure to abide by the
restrictions.6
• Part 6 of the NTER Act limits the consideration of indigenous customary law or the
cultural practice of an offender in criminal proceedings for all alleged offences (not
just those involving domestic or sexual violence), in bail applications and
sentencing.
• The Australian Crime Commission is accorded special powers, approved for use by
the National Indigenous Violence and Child Abuse Intelligence Taskforce, to
enhance its ability to collect information on alleged crime affecting indigenous
communities. These include secrecy and witness confidentiality provisions, and
special access to individuals’ records.
14.
The Special Rapporteur cannot avoid observing that, on their face, these measures
involve racial discrimination. Under the International Convention on the Elimination of All
Forms of Racial Discrimination (“Convention to Eliminate Discrimination”), to which
Australia is a party, “the term ‘racial discrimination’ shall mean any distinction, exclusion,
restriction or preference based on race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin which
has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise,
on an equal footing, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic,
social, cultural or any other field of public life” (art. 1.1).
5
6
GE.10-13887
The Special Rapporteur heard reports that the termination of the CDEP has had both negative effects
on Aboriginal employees who are left to seek work into the formal labour market without adequate
alternative employment options or training, and on employers, who have lost funds with which to hire
Aboriginal employees thereby, abruptly reducing their potential workforce.
These maximum fines are, with respect to alcohol restrictions: AUD 1,100 for the first office, $2,200
for the second or subsequent offences, and $74,800 and/or 18 months in jail for supplying/intending
to supply over 1,350 ml quantity of pure alcohol in liquor to a third person; and with respect to the
prohibited materials restrictions, $5,500 for “level 1 material and” $11,000 for “level 2 material”.
29