E/CN.4/2003/85/Add.2
page 8
14.
Mexico has ratified most of the international and regional human rights treaties, including
the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and
Members of Their Families. The Special Rapporteur congratulates Mexico on the international
commitments it has undertaken and recommends that it should ratify those treaties to which it is
not yet a party.
15.
The above-mentioned international commitments undertaken by Mexico are reflected at
the national level in the ratification of the international instruments by Congress. In addition to
the Constitution of the United Mexican States, the most relevant legislation concerning migration
in Mexico is the General Population Act and its regulations, the Citizenship Act, the Regulations
governing the Ministry of the Interior and the decree establishing the INM. These laws and
regulations govern migration procedures, establishing migrants’ duties and the limits on their
rights, but do not explicitly and exhaustively list the obligations of the Mexican State with regard
to the protection of the human rights of migrants. Rather, these rights are regulated by secondary
laws.
16.
The Special Rapporteur is concerned about the parts of the General Population Act
dealing with criminal penalties (up to 10 years’ imprisonment) for undocumented migrants. This
law criminalizes on undocumented migrants and can even be applied to the victims of trafficking
and smuggling. Several officials told the Special Rapporteur that, in practice, this law is not
applied strictly and that illegal migrants are usually deported or expelled without being punished
under criminal law. This apparent gap between the law and practice leaves room for some
discretion, which might in some cases have given rise to abuse and arbitrary action.1 The
Special Rapporteur feels it should be pointed out that, as far as criminalization is concerned, the
Protocol against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea and Air, which supplements the
United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, states that migrants who are
victims of illegal smuggling of persons or related activities are not subject to criminal
proceedings. The Special Rapporteur invites Mexico to use the Protocol as a frame of reference
in these matters.
III.
MIGRANTS IN TRANSIT THROUGH MEXICO:
GROUNDS FOR CONCERN
17.
Mexico has a recognized tradition of accepting migrants and asylum-seekers, as reflected
not only in its foreign policy but also in a number of domestic initiatives to help migrants. These
measures include programmes to legalize migrants, as is done, for example, in the case of former
Guatemalan refugees who have not returned to their country, and opportunities for individuals or
organizations to sponsor a migrant’s stay in Mexico. Some of the largest migratory flows in the
world - many of them illegal - take place in Mexico. The Special Rapporteur observed that
migrants are nevertheless vulnerable during the whole of their journey through Mexico.
Extortion and attacks on the physical integrity and dignity of migrants
18.
The Special Rapporteur observed a general climate of harassment and exploitation of the
vulnerability of migrants. She believes that efforts to protect migrants’ dignity should be stepped
up as a matter of urgency by all concerned. She heard testimony from men, women and children
who had been attacked by criminal gangs specializing in attacking foreign migrants in transit.2