Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights) on a non-discriminatory basis.
Mr. Peter Hyll-Larsen, Coordinator, Right to Education Project, Action Aid International,
UK, made reference to the “4 As” formulation and highlighted the complaint mechanisms
and legal instruments available through the various human rights mechanisms including
the Treaty Bodies. He encouraged, if possible, to go further and to frame even more
systematically and rigorously the issue in the language of these “4 As”, as done in for
example General Comment 13 from the CESCR. This should go both for these
recommendations themselves, and for what action these recommendations recommend:
i.e new laws and policies at the national level.
Mr. Charles Masabo, Member of the Senate, Burundi, discussed the location of schools
and the impact of residential patterns as well as the exclusion of members of minorities
from schools and their dropout rates. He also discussed recommendation 30 with respect
to adequate resources. Mr. Masabo’s recommendations for addressing equal access to
quality education for minorities include awareness-raising, implementation of education
infrastructure in villages and support for revenue generating activities.
Ms. Helen Pinnock of Save the Children, UK, spoke about the principle of nondiscrimination in securing equal access to education, barriers to access to education that
are compounded, and impediments resulting from poverty. Specifically, Ms. Pinnock
recommended that the Forum should promote monitoring mechanisms which hold
decision makers accountable to providing flexible approaches to education delivery,
which respond to and value the diverse cultures, identities and contexts present in the
population.
Ms. Doris Angst, Director, Federal Commission Against Racism (FCR) – Switzerland
spoke about national minorities, migrant workers and refugees, the discrimination they
face on the basis of ethnic origin and the positive results that can emanate from positive
actions by third parties. She recommended the inclusion of a paragraph in the
recommendations that States should promote and finance such positive actions by third
parties which aim at granting equal access to education.
Ms. Barbara Wilson, UN Expert and Member of the Committee on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights, highlighted the recent adoption of the Optional Protocol to the
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural rights by the General Assembly
and the potential use of the individual complaint mechanism to address discrimination in
education. Ms. Wilson also discussed the forthcoming likely adoption of General
Comment 20 on non-discrimination, which is a potential tool for addressing
discrimination in education.
Mr. Prasad Kariyawasam, UN Expert and Member of the Committee on Migrant Workers
underlined the issue of equal access to quality education for migrant workers and
members of their family.
Discussion under item IV was grouped together with discussion under Item V.
10