Understanding the root causes of violence and atrocity crimes
Speaking notes – Diane Ala’i
When we look at understanding the root causes of violence and atrocity crimes a concept
that comes to mind is the idea of 'otherness'.
This 'otherness' very often stems from ignorance, so we do not only see the 'other' as
separate from us, but the mere thought of it also raises suspicion. It thus becomes a
breeding ground for spreading lies and creating myths. It is interesting to note that the lies
that are spread are generally very well thought through and culturally designed to tap into
primordial fears - spy of the enemy, related to sexual offenses, children, secret societies …
(and all the persecuted minorities can recognize these accusations).
Of course, hate speech is the ultimate form of this type of behaviour, but there are many
shades of such acts that erode and strive to eliminate the most basic of our commonality
which is the fact that we belong to one common humanity. For example, in the Special
Rapporteur on cultural rights' report to the General Assembly last year on 'The writing and
teaching of history' she states: 'Distortions of history teaching are not restricted to
post-conflict societies. In many societies, history teaching either altogether ignores or
carries, validates or strengthens stereotypes about marginalized groups, especially
minorities and indigenous peoples, in addition to women and the poor.'
This otherness can then be used by 'Ethnic conflict entrepreneurs' – a term coined by Asbjorn
Eide in 1993, or more recently what I would call 'religious exclusivity entrepreneurs'.
There is a lot of talk about situations of conflict, and rightly so given the present
circumstances. But unfortunately atrocity crimes are not the exclusivity of conflicts, yet they
get far less attention when they are regularly and relentlessly perpetrated.
The 'otherness' takes a special dimension when it is actually promoted by a government,
when whatever means are available to a particular government are used to ostracize a
minority.
Imagine a situation where:
- A government allows schoolteachers to discriminate and ridicule pupils belonging to a
minority. Telling other pupils not to associate with them, or when they have to drink from a
different water fountain than all the others - imagine being subjected to that when you are
6... 8...
- A government does not allow any youth from a particular minority to attends universities
- A government uses the concept of 'impurity' or 'uncleanliness' to forbid members of a
minority to work in the public sector and exercise a certain number of professions in the
private one
- A government does not allow members of a minority to bury their dead in a dignified
manner, with name plates, to leave flowers on the graves of their loved ones, to beautify the
wasteland given to them by planting trees
- and finally imagine that a government uses all the media it has at its disposal to spread
false accusations against a particular minority.