A/71/285
A study 5 undertaken over a period of 14 years into the effects of non-European
Union migration on 15 Western European countries showed that, by taking manual
jobs, migrants pushed European Union nationals to wards more highly skilled and
better-paid jobs. A significant increase in more complex skills among nationals was
noted. The labour market adjusted with no significant impact on the employment
rates for European Union nationals. The impact of the global re cession was shown
to temper but not eradicate this positive phenomenon, debunking the argument that
an economic downturn justifies repressive policies against migrants.
33. Similarly, conceptions of migrants as a “burden” are not based on facts and
serve political objectives. Against a backdrop of fiscal and demographic challenges
and of austerity policies, discussing external migration as a “burden” and focusing
on the need to share this “burden” across different Member States again legitimizes
the further securing of borders and encourages negative public attitudes. Economic
studies demonstrate that, as workers, consumers and taxpayers, migrants contribute
to the economic growth of societies, with very limited downside effects
(see A/HRC/29/36). In fact, the perceived “burden” of migration comes
predominantly from the financial, technological and human resources necessary to
implement counterproductive national security-focused policies and to deal with
their unintended, although foreseeable, secondary effects.
34. Acknowledging that migrants are human beings with rights, States should be
talking about sharing a “responsibility”, not a “burden”, and considering the costs
for welcoming refugees and migrants as an investment, not an expense. All studies
show that the return on the investment is well worth it.
35. A global compact based on the core principles and provisions of international
and regional law could stop the widespread suffering of migrants in trans it, at
borders and in destination countries. Applying the United Nations core values to
policies based on fact rather than fiction would lead to migration policies that
facilitate mobility and promote diversity. The development of a global compact with
a long-term vision supporting a human rights-based framework will become
increasingly vital to the internal and external interests of States as they face
demographic, societal and labour market challenges. Committing to a global
compact that recognizes the benefits of mobility will provide better protection for
the human rights of migrants and will better equip States to sustain recovery,
encourage growth and further develop global competitiveness.
36. Fully implementing a global compact relying on a human rights-based
framework for regular migration therefore involves a number of policy orientations,
including:
(a)
Increasing search-and-rescue capacity;
(b) Developing rights-based alternatives to detention and expeditiously and
completely ending the immigration detention of children and families;
(c) Considerably reducing underground labour markets and exploitation in
the workplace over the coming decade, as they act as a magnet for irregular
migration at the request of exploitative employers;
__________________
5
8/24
Francesco D’Amuri and Giovanni Peri, “Immigration, jobs and employment protection: evidence
from Europe before and during the Great Recession”, Bank of Italy working paper, No. 886
(University of California, Davis, 2012).
16-13509