A/55/304
Governments, since that appeared to be an attempt at
normalization of such parties through the democratic
process, if not the democratic paradox (namely, the
accession to power through democratic channels of a
party which disavows the fundamental principles of
democracy, including respect for human rights without
distinction as to, inter alia, race, origin or colour).
There was a genuine risk that the Austrian example
might be widely emulated and that such organizations,
which had been losing ground in many countries, might
regain political momentum and public support.
8.
The Special Rapporteur also referred to the
punitive raids by hundreds of Spaniards against the
North African (mostly Moroccan) inhabitants of the
town of El Ejido in southern Spain on Saturday, 5
February 2000, following the murder of a young
Spanish woman by a Moroccan who was mentally
unbalanced. Forty-nine people had been injured,
considerable property belonging to the foreigners had
been destroyed and the victims had been the target of
xenophobic and racist remarks. Spain, which had just
liberalized its immigration policy to take account of its
declining birth rate and the manpower needs of its
booming economy, had been surprised and shocked at
this violent manifestation of racism and xenophobia,
which it had managed to contain through the
intervention of over 500 police.
9.
Lastly, the Special Rapporteur mentioned the case
of Amadou Diallo, a young Guinean immigrant, who
on 4 February 1999 had died after being shot 41 times
by four New York City policemen. The Special
Rapporteur noted that the four policemen charged with
his murder had been acquitted. While refraining from
comment on the verdict, he echoed Amnesty
International in observing that “The Diallo case is one
of more than a dozen incidents in the past five years, in
which black, Hispanic or other minorities have been
shot
in
highly
questionable
and
disputed
circumstances” and cited President Clinton’s comment,
broadcast by Radio France Internationale on 4 March,
that Amadou Diallo would not have died had he been
living in a white neighbourhood.
10. In addition to those extremely disturbing cases,
the Special Rapporteur referred to the expansion of the
dissemination of racist ideologies on the Internet and
reiterated his recommendation that, in addition to the
workshops already held, international consultations
should be held to determine what must be done to curb
4
that harmful activity, which seemed to know no
borders.
11. The Special Rapporteur also recalled that the
Roma were victims of racial discrimination in a
number of countries, and referred the Commission to
the preliminary findings of his regional mission to the
Czech Republic, Romania and Hungary from 20 to 30
September 1999 (see E/CN.4/2000/16/Add.1).
12. Concerning the follow-up to earlier missions, he
mentioned that the South African Government had
implemented his recommendations through a set of
measures to combat xenophobia and recurrent forms of
racism and racial discrimination. A plan of action
against xenophobia and a campaign to increase
tolerance towards foreigners had been launched. The
Parliament had adopted new legislation, consisting of
four laws, designed to promote equality through
affirmative action and to prevent and punish different
manifestations of racial discrimination.
13. He said that the French Government had acted on
his recommendations, made following his visit to
France in September 1995, by putting in place a major
legislative package against racism. The immigration
laws had been revised, the procedure for granting entry
visas to France to people from the “South” had been
relaxed and the procedure for reviewing the cases of
people held at detention centres, as well as the grounds
for expulsion, had been made more consistent with
respect for human rights. However, there was a risk
that those efforts might be undermined by the recent
turnaround in French public opinion. An opinion poll
conducted between 17 and 24 November 1999 at the
request of the National Consultative Commission on
Human Rights and the Government’s information
service showed that 69 per cent of French people
considered themselves to be “quite racist”, “rather
racist” or “not very racist”, while only 29 per cent
considered themselves to be “not at all racist”. The
feelings of solidarity and brotherhood among all
French people regardless of origin, engendered by the
victory of France’s national team in the World Cup
final, seemed to have given way to tensions concerning
immigration issues. According to the National
Consultative Commission on Human Rights, acts of
xenophobia, racism and anti-Semitism were on the rise.
The French Government had expressed its concern and
had announced a plan to combat racial discrimination.