A/HRC/14/36
IV.
Areas of concern and priority issues for the mandate
42.
The present chapter contains an overview of the main issues the independent expert
proposes to address as a priority in the course of her mandate, in addition to the proposals
made above to further define the conceptual and legal framework of cultural rights. The
independent expert is not suggesting that she will have the capacity to address all these
issues in full detail, nor that she will confine herself only to these issues, as this will also
depend upon her resources and opportunities.
43.
For each issue, the independent expert, as requested in resolution 10/23 of the
Human Rights Council, will seek to identify best practices and possible obstacles for the
realization of cultural rights. She will work in cooperation with States to foster the
formulation and adoption of measures at the local, national, regional and international
levels aimed at the promotion and protection of cultural rights through concrete proposals
enhancing subregional, regional and international cooperation in that regard. She will
integrate a gender and disabilities perspective into her work, and in more general terms,
address the situation of disadvantaged and marginalized groups in the enjoyment of cultural
rights. Depending on available resources, she also proposes to organize consultations, in
particular regional consultations on some of these issues.
A.
Cultural rights, globalization of exchanges and of information, and
development processes
44.
There is a growing perception that globalization leads to cultural homogenization.
This raises the question of how best to assess the accuracy of such a perception and what
measures, if any, are required to ensure the enjoyment of cultural rights in this context.
45.
UNESCO addresses this issue in its 2009 World Report. Rather than understanding
globalization as a “unidirectional and unidimensional process, driven by a Westerndominated global market economy and tending to standardize, streamline and
transnationalize in ways inimical to cultural diversity”,39 the report proposes an
understanding of globalization as a multidirectional and multidimensional process.
According to the report “globalization can be described in terms of the increasing ‘flows’ of
virtually everything that characterizes contemporary life: capital, commodities, knowledge,
information, ideas, people, beliefs and so on. These flows — transiting essentially through
the media, communication networks and commerce — consist of an ever-increasing
volume of cultural goods, services and communications, including language and
educational content”.40
46.
It is important to bear in mind that some societies and communities are more
vulnerable to, and marginalized by this process than others and that concerns about the
impact of globalization on cultural rights are expressed in both developing and developed
countries. It is also important not to underestimate the anxiety and tensions that rapid
cultural changes may cause, especially when they are felt to be imposed. Here, several
points must be taken into consideration. First, intercultural exchanges and therefore mutual
integration have always existed between societies and communities through information,
commerce and migration. Second, the extent to which anxiety and tensions related to
cultural changes are felt varies amongst individuals within the same community, for
example amongst generations. Third, culture being a dynamic and living process, taking
39
40
GE.10-12440
p. 13.
Ibid., p. 14.
15