A/HRC/34/56/Add.1
39.
Cypriots must come together to produce joint documentation of all the destruction
that has taken place and to write the history of all the heritage that has been destroyed. That
critical task could be performed through a truth commission representative of the diversity
of the population of Cyprus. The purpose would be to gather and complete existing
documentation, assemble narratives of the losses for all and begin writing a common
history, with a view to redressing violations of cultural rights as part of any settlement or
thereafter.
40.
The destruction of cultural heritage has created huge impediments to the exercise of
the right to access and enjoy cultural heritage, and jeopardizes the rights of future
generations. Some of the heritage can no longer serve as sources of knowledge and mutual
understanding, as places to conduct rituals and cultural practices, or as venues for social
interaction or building friendships across groups, irrespective of affiliation.
41.
The Special Rapporteur is concerned that one purpose of the patterns of destruction
has been to deprive displaced people of anything to which they could return, as well as to
erase the history of their presence and claim a monopoly or monolithic identity in particular
locales. Displaced people on both sides of the island expressed to the Special Rapporteur
their desire to see their heritage restored as a prelude to their ability to return to their former
homes, or at least to re-establish relationships with their places of origin.
42.
Many cultural heritage sites that the Special Rapporteur visited had been restored or
were undergoing restoration. She also visited and was informed of sites that were in a
terrible condition, as is the case for many abandoned churches and mosques that are
neglected and left exposed to vandalism. She also visited other sites that need further
protection, such as the archaeological site of Ayia Trias/Sipahi Basilica/Bazilikasi in the
north. For a long time left without any care and exposed to damage from livestock, the site
is now guarded and there are projects to protect better the mosaics and remaining structures
of this fifth-century site.
(b)
Devastating effects of looting on cultural rights
43.
An important related issue concerns the looting of artefacts. Sacred objects, icons
and frescoes have been removed illegally from abandoned churches in the north and sold on
the international market. Looting has been widespread and systematically organized,
causing much suffering to people who have seen their churches, museums and
archaeological sites completely plundered.
44.
The Special Rapporteur salutes the work undertaken by the Department of
Antiquities in monitoring the auctions carried out abroad and on the Internet, and their
dedication in repatriating items. The legal difficulties, administrative challenges and costs
linked with locating and repatriating artefacts are huge. It is difficult, for example, to prove
the exact provenance of the items, as archives have been lost or destroyed during looting
and as not all items had been registered. Although experts are able to identify cultural
heritage of Cyprus, thanks to the specific techniques employed to create the artworks, they
are in many cases unable to identify their exact original location, such as specific churches
or museums. The Aydin Dikmen case exemplifies these obstacles.11
45.
The Special Rapporteur also notes information alleging that unregistered collections
have been found in the hands of private collectors in the south of the island and abroad.12
(c)
Changing of cultural landscapes
46.
The destruction of cultural heritage has considerably changed the symbolic,
historical and cultural landscape in all areas of Cyprus. An additional effort to alter the
landscape is the systematic changing of the names of places, streets and villages in the
north. Some argue that such changes are part of a nationalistic campaign of ethnic cleansing
against Greek Cypriots.
11
12
See cyprus-mail.com/2015/03/16/cyprus-loses-fight-for-ancient-artefacts.
See cyprus-mail.com/2016/11/12/cyprus-police-coordinated-europe-wide-pandora-operation-huntmissing-antiquities.
9