A/72/186
distinct peoples, with specific cultures and relation to certain lands and territories,
and have been subject to marginalization. The problems they suffer, related to their
group identity, are similar to those of peoples all over the world that identify as
indigenous, and are the types of problems that the Declaration seeks to resolve as a
remedial instrument. The work of the African Commission on Human and Peoples ’
Rights, particularly its Working Group on indigenous populations/communities, has
been instrumental in advancing a positive dialogue on the recognition of indigenous
peoples in the African region. 20
24. The sections that follow contain comments on progress made and challenges
remaining within three key spheres that the mandate holder has had the opportunity
of assessing in country missions, working visits, exchanges with State
representatives, indigenous peoples and others, and through communications work,
namely, the development of an adequate legal framework, the adoption and
implementation of enabling public policies and the establishment of adequate
institutional arrangements. 21
VI. Necessary legal reforms
25. The existence of an adequate legal framework, consistent with international
human rights standards, particularly the Declaration, is not per se a guarantee of
implementation, but is an important step to establishing a solid basis to build the
necessary changes. As noted by my predecessors, even in countries with well developed enabling legal frameworks on the rights of indigenous peoples, there may
be “implementation gaps” that impede effective actions. 22
26. The legal framework may consist of a combination of constitutional
recognition and specific legal instruments devoted to the rights of indigenous
peoples in general or on different sectoral issues. In some cou ntries, such as Canada,
New Zealand and the United States of America, treaties were signed between
indigenous peoples and States which provide a legal basis for domestic recognition
of indigenous peoples’ rights. 23 There is an ongoing discussion of the possibility of
development of a treaty in Australia. 24 There are also different kinds of agreements
__________________
20
21
22
23
24
17-12399
Report of the African Commission’s Working Group of Experts on Indigenous
Populations/Communities, submitted in accordance with the “Resolution on the Rights of
Indigenous Populations/Communities in Africa” adopted by the African Commission on Human
and Peoples’ Rights at its 28th ordinary session (2005).
Since 2007, mandate holders have made official visits to Brazil (2008, 2016), Nepal (2008),
Australia (2009, 2017), Botswana (2009), Colombia (2009), the Russian Federation (2009),
Guatemala (2010), New Zealand (2010), the Republic of the Congo (2010), the Sápmi region in
Norway, Sweden and Finland (2010, 2015), Argentina (2011), New Caledonia, France (2011),
El Salvador (2012), Namibia (2012), the United States of America (2012, 2017), Canada (2013),
Panama (2013), Peru (2013), Paraguay (2014) and Honduras (2015); and working visits, among
others, to Ecuador (2008, 2009), Chile (2009), Panama (2009), Peru (2009), Costa Rica (2011),
Suriname (2011) and Honduras (2015), in addition to attending numerous meetings and events in
different countries by invitation of Government authorities, the United Nations system,
academia, indigenous peoples and civil society organizations. All official country mission reports
of mandate holders are available from www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/IPeoples/SRIndigenousPeoples/
Pages/CountryReports.aspx.
See A/HRC/9/9 (2008); and E/CN.4/2006/78.
See A/HRC/18/35/Add.4 (mission report of the Special Rapporteur on New Zealand (2011),
analysing the settlement procedure for the Treaty of Waitangi); A/HRC/27/52/Add.2 (mission
report of the Special Rapporteur on Canada (2014), on new agreements and treaty settlements);
and A/HRC/21/47/Add.1 (mission report of the Special Rapporteur on the United States of
America (2012), section on broken treaties).
See A/HRC/36/46/Add.2 (mission report of the Special Rapporteur on Australia (2017), on the
outcome of a referendum consultation indicating preference for a treaty).
7/23