A/HRC/60/29
I. Introduction
1.
The twentieth anniversary of the adoption, in 2007, of the United Nations Declaration
on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples is approaching. The Declaration provides a framework
for the recognition of Indigenous Peoples and establishes minimum standards for the
protection of their rights worldwide. It has enhanced constitutional and legal recognition of
Indigenous Peoples in various countries across the world.
2.
However, misunderstanding of the meaning of the term “Indigenous Peoples”
continues to hamper the implementation of the Declaration. In Africa and Asia, in particular,
many States are still hesitant to recognize Indigenous Peoples, as they misunderstand the
term as divisive or seeking to privilege certain groups over others.
3.
The present report by the Special Rapporteur on the rights of Indigenous Peoples is
not aimed at experts in Indigenous Peoples’ rights. The purpose of the report is rather to
present foundational concepts and principles concerning Indigenous Peoples and their rights,
to facilitate understanding and adoption of these concepts by States that are facing challenges
in their understanding.
4.
The term “Indigenous Peoples” has become a human rights call for justice. It is a
demand for redress, made by distinct peoples that suffered or continue to suffer historical
injustices, grounded in racial discrimination, which led to loss of their ancestral lands and
distinct culture. The Declaration was formulated to address this injustice and foster
reconciliation and partnership between Indigenous Peoples and States.
5.
States should recognize Indigenous Peoples as specific rights holders under
international law. However, State recognition neither creates Indigenous Peoples nor grants
them their rights. The rights of Indigenous Peoples are guaranteed under international law,
and they are binding on States regardless of recognition in domestic laws. Refusal by a State
to recognize Indigenous Peoples, or denial by a State of their existence on its territory, does
not diminish the rights held by Indigenous Peoples.
6.
The report provides regional contextualization of the concept of “Indigenous Peoples”
in Africa and Asia. It also addresses the conflation of Indigenous Peoples with local
communities, which contributes to misunderstandings and can undermine the recognition of
Indigenous Peoples by States.
II. States’ obligation to recognize Indigenous Peoples
7.
States have the obligation to recognize Indigenous Peoples as particular subjects of
international law, and holders of specific rights under international law. Without such
recognition, States cannot fulfil their international obligations under the Declaration 1 and
other international instruments. However, international human rights law is not prescriptive
as to the model through which Indigenous Peoples must be recognized. The aim of the present
report is to provide recommendations for closing this outstanding human rights gap.
8.
In the present section, the legal framework for recognition is outlined, the
implementation steps are detailed and the negative effect of conflating Indigenous Peoples
with local communities on recognition is examined.
A.
Normative framework of the obligation of States to recognize
Indigenous Peoples
9.
The Declaration is premised on an acknowledgement of the historical injustices that
Indigenous Peoples have suffered. It constitutes a reaffirmation the obligation of States to
recognize Indigenous Peoples as rights holders, including of the right to self-determination,
to overcome past and present patterns of discrimination.2
1
2
2
Declaration, preamble and art. 38.
See ibid., preamble.
GE.25-12002