A/HRC/60/29
mechanisms for upholding the rights of Indigenous Peoples, especially where constitutional
reforms are politically or procedurally challenging.
83.
National court decisions and international bodies often prompt legal recognition of
Indigenous Peoples through legislation. They play a crucial role in interpreting constitutional
guarantees, enforcing human rights standards, and holding Governments to account for
injustices affecting Indigenous Peoples.
84.
However, Indigenous Peoples are often excluded from legislative processes, resulting
in laws that do not reflect their priorities or lived realities. Many laws are hard to enforce
owing to vague provisions, insufficient funding or weak institutions. In some countries,
overlapping laws lead to confusion and uncertainty, particularly when they violate
Indigenous customary laws. Furthermore, legislation can be amended or repealed more easily
than constitutional provisions, which may affect the stability of rights. In some cases, laws
recognize Indigenous identity or status without providing for significant rights or protections,
resulting in primarily symbolic recognition.
85.
Federal systems can influence the recognition of Indigenous Peoples in various ways,
as different entities within a State may possess different degrees of autonomy. Certain
federated states may independently recognize Indigenous Peoples and have more progressive
laws than those at the federal level. Such differences could lead to legal inconsistencies and
fragmented enforcement between federal and state laws.
86.
Some States have addressed the recognition of Indigenous Peoples through legislation
that establishes national representative institutions. Nordic countries have established Sami
parliaments as part of their efforts to recognize the rights of Indigenous Peoples. Often such
legislation serves to implement constitutional provisions.
87.
Several countries have passed laws for the recognition of Indigenous Peoples in
compliance with courts’ decisions or constitutional requirements.
88.
Many Latin American countries have recognized Indigenous Peoples through acts of
parliament. Countries in this region have adopted some supportive legal frameworks, further
elaborated on by court decisions. The Supreme Court of Panama has stated that the
Government must secure for Indigenous communities the necessary lands and collective land
rights to these lands for the achievement of their economic and social well-being.70
89.
In Europe, several countries have passed laws to recognize Indigenous Peoples. The
Greenland Self-Government Act, of 2009, recognizes the people of Greenland as a people
under international law with the right to self-determination. The Act enables Greenland to
take over responsibility for most of its internal matters and establishes that the people of
Greenland can decide to seek independence. 71 As a result of growing Sami political
mobilization and State recognition, Norway established the Sami Parliament under the Sami
Act, of 1987, recognizing the Sami as an Indigenous People and granting them a degree of
cultural autonomy. The Sami Parliament promotes Sami interests, language and culture. It
operates independently, setting its own priorities and policies, and serves as both a political
and administrative institution for the Sami people.72 The establishment in 1993 of the Sami
Parliament of Sweden is regarded as a recognition of the status of the Sami as an Indigenous
People. Contrary to Norway, Sweden has not ratified the ILO Indigenous and Tribal Peoples
Convention, 1989 (No. 169). Nevertheless, the Swedish courts have utilized the Convention
and the Declaration as key sources of law.73 In a ruling regarding the Sami village of Girjas,
for example, the Supreme Court referred to the ILO Convention and the Declaration to
substantiate the rights of the Sami people.74
90.
In North America, the United States does not have a single comprehensive act on
recognition of all Indigenous Peoples. In 1971, Congress enacted the Alaska Native Claims
70
71
72
73
74
16
See Center for International Environmental Law, “Panama’s Supreme Court recognizes Indigenous
Peoples’ land rights and role as guardians of the environment”, 20 January 2021.
A/HRC/54/31/Add.1, para. 8.
See https://sametinget.no/about-the-sami-parliament/.
Submission by the Saami Council.
See Cultural Survival, “Historic court ruling upholds Sami rights in Sweden”, 14 February 2020.
GE.25-12002