A/HRC/60/29
47.
Regardless of the chosen approach, it is essential that Indigenous Peoples are formally
recognized as distinct peoples with the right to self-determination, that the specific historical
injustices that they suffered are acknowledged and that provisions are adopted for restitution,
remedy and reparation. Recognition should guarantee effective governing and representative
institutions for Indigenous Peoples. As the cultural identity of Indigenous Peoples passes
through their own institutions, States should legally recognize and support effective
institutions for self-governance, decision-making and representation, as stipulated in the
Declaration.43
48.
States may recognize Indigenous Peoples through their constitutions, treaties, statutes,
sectoral laws, regulations or policies. Recognition at a higher level of the legal hierarchy
generally results in broader and stronger protection of Indigenous Peoples.
3.
Identification of Indigenous Peoples
49.
States’ recognition of Indigenous Peoples should also involve an effective process for
constructively identifying the specific peoples within the relevant jurisdiction. Such localized
and contextualized identification allows States to fulfil their duty to prevent cultural
assimilation of Indigenous Peoples or any action that has the aim or effect of depriving them
of their integrity as distinct peoples, or of their cultural values or ethnic identities. 44 The
specific identification process also allows a State to develop appropriate measures, such as
the delivery of public services to Indigenous Peoples in an effective manner, while
safeguarding their identity from pretenders or fraudsters.
50.
However, such a process of identifying the specific Indigenous Peoples with respect
to whom they have obligations does not give States the right to define Indigenous Peoples or
determine their rights. Rather, States must abide by the fundamental principle of selfidentification as a core criterion. As specified in the Declaration, Indigenous Peoples have
the right to determine their own identity or membership in accordance with their customs and
traditions. 45 In a similar vein, the ILO Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989
(No. 169), under article 1 (2), requires that self-identification as Indigenous be regarded as a
fundamental criterion for determining the groups to which the provisions of the Convention
apply.
51.
Furthermore, the norm of “self-identification” is a means of restoring Indigenous
Peoples’ self-esteem and confidence, counteracting centuries of marginalization, including
in decisions about their own destiny. It also provides for Indigenous Peoples to assume
greater control over their own future.
52.
An effective process of identification of specific Indigenous Peoples by States should
therefore be based on the fundamental right of Indigenous Peoples to determine their own
identity (self-identification), combined with the objectively distinguishing characteristics
(criteria), understood as the historical injustices the peoples concerned suffer and continue to
suffer. The ILO Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169), in its article 1,
lists additional objective characteristics that can guide States to clearly identify Indigenous
Peoples, including descent from the populations who inhabited the country, or a geographical
region to which the country belongs, at the time of conquest or colonization or the
establishment of present State boundaries and who, irrespective of their legal status, retain
some or all of their own social, economic, cultural and political institutions.
53.
A State may request supplementary information from Indigenous Peoples during
registration processes; however, any such information should be available to Indigenous
Peoples and the decisions by the State in any identification process must remain open to
judicial review and legal challenge. Such specific identification processes must be inclusive
of those Indigenous Peoples who may have lost access to ancestral lands or languages or
whose traditional institutions have been undermined. Indigenous individuals in urban areas,
therefore, must also have access to protection.
43
44
45
10
Ibid., art. 5.
Ibid., art. 8 (2) (a).
Ibid., art. 33 (1).
GE.25-12002