A/HRC/36/46/Add.2
years, which disproportionately affects indigenous peoples. 25 The Special Rapporteur was
informed about measures in place by the Australian Electoral Commission to increase the
number of indigenous voters, but urges that those measures be reinforced, in consultation
with indigenous communities and organizations, as a matter of priority in order to improve
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders’ exercise of their right to political participation.
Q.
Land rights and native title
98.
As with other indigenous peoples around the world, land rights are central to the
cultural identity and economic development of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders. 2017
marks the twenty-fifth anniversary of the landmark Mabo decision, which held that the
common law of Australia recognized native titles held by indigenous peoples to their
traditional lands. The decision led to the adoption of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), which
set out the processes for determining native title rights. The rights of Aboriginals and
Torres Strait Islanders to around 30 per cent of the land area of the country are formally
recognized, yet in most instances only “non-exclusive” rights are recognized. A further 27
per cent of Australia territory is subject to native title claims, processes that are extremely
protracted.
99.
In order to succeed, claimants under the Native Title Act must prove that they have
had an uninterrupted connection to the area being claimed, and that they have continued to
practice their traditional laws and customs. This is an extraordinary challenge and burden of
proof in the context of the historical forced removal and dispossession policies of Australia.
The Special Rapporteur furthermore notes the complex system with multiple and
overlapping legal regimes applicable to native title claims and land rights at the federal,
state and territory levels. There are insufficient indigenous legal professionals with
expertise on land rights claims, which continues to disadvantage communities seeking to
exercise their rights.
100. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders have been negotiating Indigenous Land Use
Agreements for years in order to, for instance, resolve native title claims or benefit from
development activities carried out on their lands. While some Agreements are controversial,
others are not and have brought important economic benefits for indigenous communities.
101. In its McGlade decision of 2 February 2017, the Federal Court created legal
uncertainty by requiring that, in order to be valid, indigenous land use agreements should
be signed by all native title claimants. The Government reacted by proposing a bill to
amend the Native Title Act. The bill, passed on 14 June 2017, validates existing agreements
already negotiated and registered before the McGlade decision, even though they had not
been signed by all native title claimants. In that regard, the Special Rapporteur recalls that
the principle of free, informed and prior consent does not require the consent of all. Having
said that, there are many different types of indigenous land use agreements and some have
far-reaching consequences on native title rights and even lead to the surrender of all native
title (as in the McGlade case).
102. The Special Rapporteur appreciated learning about the joint management of
protected areas for conservation in several parts of the country, including in Kimberley. The
creation and joint management of those protected areas allow traditional owners to continue
to enjoy their customary practices, while providing conservation and direct employment
opportunities for indigenous peoples. The Special Rapporteur was also encouraged by the
highly successful government-funded indigenous rangers’ programme, which supports
indigenous peoples’ connection to their lands, encourages cultural knowledge transfer,
provides skilled employment and simultaneously contributes to conservation. 26
103. During the visit, she was informed about successful native title claimants who
wished to declare their lands protected areas but faced administrative obstacles in doing so.
She encourages the authorities to take steps to facilitate the extension of protected areas
25
26
See https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2016/australia.
See www.dpmc.gov.au/indigenous-affairs/environment/indigenous-rangers-working-country.
17