E/CN.4/2004/63/Add.2
page 18
such as churches, and other property. To the Orthodox way of thinking, sacred property belongs
to the community of believers. The Orthodox Church leaders point out that this is not the way
the Roman Catholic Church sees it. Consequently, before an Orthodox church can be handed
over to someone else, the entire community must give its consent. Given this requirement, a
settlement through the courts is inconceivable to Orthodox leaders, since, according to them,
“human justice cannot replace divine justice”.
3. Results of action by Greek Catholics
84.
In the meantime, only 150 of the 2,600 churches claimed have actually been returned to
Greek Catholics. Of these, 50 have been returned thanks to the personal commitment of
Nicholae Corneanu, the Orthodox Bishop of Banat, who has been strongly criticized by the
Orthodox hierarchy for promoting restitution. The other churches have been returned following
court decisions or as a result of the reconversion of entire communities of Greek Catholics to
their original faith.
85.
In this context, members of the Greek Catholic community in Romania spoke to the
Special Rapporteur of their deep despair and strongly criticized the attitude of the Romanian
authorities for failing to intervene in cases of restitution.
86.
The Special Rapporteur was also informed that a number of Greek Catholic churches had
been illegally destroyed by Orthodox communities. This is allegedly the case of the Greek
Catholic churches in Vadu Izei, Baisora, Smig, Tritenii de Jos and Craiova. Moreover, other
churches were still threatened with destruction at the time of the Special Rapporteur’s visit.
87.
With regard to other property confiscated from the Greek Catholic Church for the use
of the State, the commission set up pursuant to the above-cited article 2 of Decree-Law
No. 126/1990 has ceased to function and only 10 per cent of the property has been returned.
Some of this property has even been sold to third parties as part of the process of privatization.
88.
Finally, less than 20 per cent of the farmland and forests that belonged to the Greek
Catholic Church have actually been returned to it, and some of them have reportedly been
handed over illegally to the Orthodox Church.
4. The case of Ocna Mures
89.
The events that took place in the parish of Ocna Mures, Transylvania, at the beginning
of 2002 offer a remarkable illustration of the situation in which the Greek Catholic Church finds
itself, even in cases where restitution has actually been granted by the courts.
90.
The church in this parish, which had been Greek Catholic since the beginning of the
nineteenth century, was confiscated in 1948 and ownership granted to the Orthodox community.
After the revolution, in the absence of a negotiated settlement between the two churches, the
Greek Catholic community went to court to claim its rights and was awarded ownership of the
church by final decision of the appeal court in Alba Iulia in 1999. Two years later, the Greek
Catholic community was granted actual possession of the church by another court decision and
on 7 February 2002 members of the Greek Catholic Church in this parish returned to their
church, some 54 years after it had been confiscated.