ACFC/31DOC(2008)001
representatives, should also be effectively involved in processes of allocation of public
support for their cultural initiatives. Moreover, when specific institutions exist for
channelling such support, persons belonging to national minorities should be adequately
represented and should be able to take part in the corresponding decision-making.21
67.
Processes of decentralisation can play an important role in creating the conditions
necessary for persons belonging to national minorities to participate effectively in cultural
life. In particular, cultural autonomy arrangements, whose aim is inter alia to delegate
competences to persons belonging to national minorities in the sphere of culture and
education, can result in increased participation of minorities in cultural life.22
68.
Additionally, when analysing the participation of minorities in cultural life, it is
important to assess their level of participation in the media. It is important that minorities
have the possibility to create and use their own media. It is, however, equally important
that they have access to and are present in mainstream media so as to be able to present
their views on issues of interest to the society at large.
3)
PARTICIPATION IN PUBLIC AFFAIRS
69.
The Advisory Committee, while considering whether persons belonging to
national minorities effectively participate in public affairs, has examined their overall
involvement in decision-making. It has not only examined their representation and
participation in various mechanisms, but also devoted particular attention to the
effectiveness of their influence on decision-making processes. The different decisionmaking arrangements which exist in the State Parties should take into account the
composition of society and reflect its diversity.
70.
Effective participation includes a wide range of possible forms, such as an
exchange of information, dialogue, informal and formal consultation and participation in
decision-making. It can be ensured through different channels, ranging from consultative
mechanisms to special parliamentary arrangements. Particular attention should be paid to
equal participation of women and men belonging to national minorities.
71.
Whatever the mechanisms chosen, persons belonging to national minorities
should be given real opportunities to influence decision-making, the outcome of which
should adequately reflect their needs. According to the Advisory Committee, mere
consultation is, as such, not a sufficient means to be considered effective participation.
72.
Representation and participation of persons belonging to national minorities in
elected bodies, public administration, judiciary and law-enforcement agencies is an
essential but not sufficient condition for effective participation. Their inclusion in elected
bodies at different levels largely depends on the constitutional traditions and guarantees
provided for by electoral legislation. The choice and modalities of the electoral system
often has a direct impact on the effectiveness of minority participation in decision21
22
See for example 2nd Opinion on Norway, adopted on 5 October 2006, paragraphs 60 and 69.
See also paragraphs from 133 to 137 below on autonomy arrangements.
22